Bills met with “ultimate developmental WR” Jeff Caldwell

Allen needed someone who’d been there, done that, as a professional wide receiver.

We’re still some months away from really getting a true glimpse of what Allen-to-Moore looks like, yet many still believe Buffalo needs to do more, if you will. Should the Bills remain focused on repairing an often-anemic wide receivers room from last season? There are no shortage of opinions, of course, and what improvement looks likes remains cloudy.

For a team that perennially contends for the Super Bowl only to exit far too early, perhaps the best move is to continue leaning on veterans. Yet, that road has mostly led to dead ends in recent seasons. Meanwhile, the one truly significant attempt to address the room via the NFL Draft (Keon Coleman) has yet to yield the expected results.

Does that mean Buffalo shouldn’t try leveraging their luck again in the draft?

While it may be fair to criticize the offensive system, the personnel cannot be overlooked. Since moving on from Stefon Diggs, it’s felt as though One Bills Drive has lacked a true plan at wide receiver. Instead, it’s appeared more as a cobbling together of whatever fit under the salary cap and otherwise.

The draft, then, should continue providing Buffalo with the best opportunity to hit on receivers. Perhaps that’s exactly what Caldwell represents as someone Melo describes as “the ultimate developmental WR in this NFL Draft.”

Caldwell’s pre-draft measurables certainly entice, with the 6’5”, 216-pound wide receiver clocking a 4.31-second 40-yard dash, while posting a 42” vertical and 11’2” broad jump. His combine athleticism results placed him first among this year’s group of wide receivers.

To claim that drafting Caldwell would be a significant attempt by the Bills at correcting the wide receiver position isn’t entirely truthful. He’s currently viewed as a Day 3 (Round 5) selection by many outlets. He lacks experience and has a very basic route tree, according to NFL.com draft analyst Lance Zierlein. Again: Caldwell is viewed as a developmental prospect. He played three seasons for Lindenwood University’s emerging football program before a transfer to the University of Cincinnati for the 2025 season. Caldwell’s senior season with the Bearcats saw him catch 32 passes for 478 yards and six touchdowns in 13 games.

One wouldn’t necessarily view Caldwell’s addition as an immediate improvement, rather someone the team could more fully develop behind the scenes. Might Caldwell fit the bill as the next receiver in line to have a career arc similar to (or surpassing) former fifth-round pick Khalil Shakir? There’s only one way to find out.