Boston Red Sox Top Prospect Dazzles in Worcester Red Sox Win

While the Boston Red Sox were in St. Louis taking on the Cardinals, Red Sox top prospect Payton Tolle was on the mound for his third start of the season with the Triple-A Worcester Red Sox on Sunday afternoon.

It's been an incredible start to the season for Worcester, which improved to 10-4 with an 8-2 win over the Columbus Clippers, the Cleveland Guardians affiliate.

Offensively, outfielder Alan Castro (SoxProspects 16th overall) powered the WooSox win at the dish; he went 2-4 with six RBIs, including a grand slam. But it was the Red Sox lefty starter who took center stage at Polar Park.

Tolle shut down a fairly representative Clippers lineup that featured Cleveland's top prospect, second baseman Travis Bazzana, who had one of the three hits Tolle allowed in the outing. Overall, it was five shutout innings for the big left-hander, striking out six and walking just one batter.

After a rocky first start of the season, where he allowed six runs (four earned) on five hits to the Syracuse Mets, Tolle shut down the St. Paul Saints, who MLB Pipeline named one of the ten most talented minor league rosters, over six innings, allowing just one earned run, striking out seven.

Overall, Tolle has allowed five earned runs on 12 hits across 15 innings of work, good for an opponent batting average of .214 and an ERA of 3.00. His 30.2 percent K-rate represents almost a 2% rise from last year's Triple-A numbers. He is, however, walking seven percent of batters, up from the ridiculous 3.4 percent he walked in 2025.

When will we see Tolle back in Boston?

Aug 29, 2025; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Boston Red Sox starting pitcher Payton Tolle (70) reacts to fans after being relieved of pitching duties against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the sixth inning at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: Eric Canha-Imagn Images

Tolle made his major league debut last year, going pitch for pitch with Paul Skenes of the Pittsburgh Pirates, but things quickly started to unravel in the two starts that followed. He allowed seven runs, four of them via home run across just five innings before being moved to the bullpen for the balance of the regular season and playoffs.

Tolle entered spring training with a clear goal of developing his secondary pitches, including the introduction of a new two-seam fastball and curveball. He was one of the biggest standouts in Spring Training for the Red Sox, allowing three runs on eight hits, striking out 13, and walking only one in 10.1 innings before ultimately losing the fifth starter job to fellow rookie Connelly Early.

In a crowded Red Sox pitching room, it's unclear where Tolle will factor into the major league equation, but as we learned last year, you can never have too many starters. When asked about their top prospect during Boston's first homestand of the season, Red Sox manager Alex Cora made it clear that Tolle would factor in for the big league club at some point, saying, "We'll see what happens... we do believe he's going to contribute at one point, without making any promises."

While it's unclear what his role may be when that call does come, if Tolle keeps throwing the ball the way he did against Columbus and St. Paul, he'll find himself back on a big league mound sooner rather than later.

JOIN THE CONVERSATION:

Remember to join our RED SOX on ROUNDTABLE community, which is FREE! You can post your own thoughts, in text or video form, and you can engage with our Roundtable staff, as well as other Red Sox fans. If prompted to download the Roundtable APP, that's free too!