Bullpen turns strong Drew Rasmussen start into nailbiter: Rays 5, Yankees 4

Apr 12, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; Tampa Bay Rays starting pitcher Drew Rasmussen (57) walks off the field after pitching against the New York Yankees in the third inning at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images | Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

I know this has been said a dozen different ways by people much more eloquent than myself, but my goodness is it ever nice to see games played at the Trop again. Haters gonna hate, but that place is special, and it’s so nice to see games under the dome again.

The Rays were wrapping up their weekend series against the Yankees, with Drew Rasmussen on the mound. A belated congrats to Drew and his family in welcoming his second child, which was why he missed his last start. Congrats to Drew and Stevie! Rasmssen was facing off against Cam Schlittler for the Yankees. Schlittler has had a strong start to the young season, so the Rays would need to get to him early.

Rasmussen got things started with a nice 1-2-3 inning in the top of the first. Into the home half, the Rays wasted no time putting pressure on their foes as Chandler Simpson hit a leadoff single. Junior Caminero singled right behind him, sending the speedy Simpson from first to third. With one out, Yandy Diaz grounded out, but it was enough for Simpson to make it home and score the first run of the game. They’d need to settle for just the one run, but it was a good start.

Full Swing pic.twitter.com/EPyKtu7M9I

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

The Yankees made their first effort to get something going in the second with a one-out double from Jazz Chisholm Jr. But two outs quickly followed to leave the runner stranded and the Yanks scoreless. In the home half, the Rays weren’t willing to rest on just one run. Cedric Mullins got a leadoff triple. A Richie Palacios groundout scored Mullins.

Make it ✌️ pic.twitter.com/uyzxKcO86n

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

Taylor Walls then singled, and right after that, he stole second. With two outs in the inning, Simpson came up and singled, bringing Walls home. Then, Simpson being Simpson, he stole second. No additional runs scored, but the Rays were up 3-0 at the end of the inning.

Walls with the wheels 🛞 pic.twitter.com/bbkCYFbGwC

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

Rasmussen continued to deal against the Yankees, getting them three-up and three-down in the top of the third. In the home half, with one out, Yandy Diaz took a walk. After another out, Mullins hit a long fly that went right to the warning track but ended up just being the final out of the inning.

The Yankees started the fourth by losing an ABS challenge. Three outs in a row put the Yankees right back in their dugout. However, in the home half, it was much the same story for the Rays, going down in order.

In the fifth, Rasmussen showed no signs of slowing down against the Yankees, getting them out in order. He had some help this inning with a truly magnificent catch by Palacios for the second out of the inning.

Richie realness pic.twitter.com/t5szHGrxCk

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

In the home half, Caminero got a one-out single. Then, with two outs, Diaz singled. But with two on, the Rays weren’t able to convert the baserunners.

Things just continued to motor along for Rasmussen as he once against made short work of the Yankees in the top of the sixth. Old friend Ryan Yarbrough was in for the Yankees in the bottom of the inning. Fun story, several years ago the Rays did an audio pronunciation guide for player names, where everyone had to say their own name. This helps broadcasters properly pronounce everyone’s names. Anyway, I’m not sure Ryan understood what he was being asked to do, because in his recording he said, “Ryan Yarbrough?” with a very audible question at the end. So for the rest of time he will forever be Ryan Yarbrough? to me. He gave up a two-out single to Taylor Walls, but the Rays couldn’t make anything work with that.

Drew Rasmussen’s day was done with a final line of 6.0 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 0 BB, 7 K on 76 pitches. Really nice outing from Drew, nice to see him get some real run support and fielding support behind it. Cole Sulser came on for the Rays in relief and unfortunately gave up a leadoff home run to Ben Rice. Kevin Cash then came out and argued that because the ball didn’t cross over the yellow poles it went into the outfield padding. The home run was overturned sending Rice back to second base on the new ground rule double. Aaron Judge walked. Cody Bellinger then singled, bringing that Rice run back in again. All with no outs, begging the question if it’s too late to bring Rasmussen back out. A groundout moved both baserunners into scoring position. This, of course, was when the Yankees decided to bring in Giacarlo Stanton and Kevin Cash made a quick move to pull the struggling Sulser. Kevin Kelly came out next, and while Stanton grounded out, he did get Judge home. A sharp lineout to left then ended the inning, but the score had gotten a lot closer than I think anyone would like it to be.

Chandler Simpson got the home half of the seventh going with a triple, chasing Ryan Yarbrough from the game. Camilo Doval was the next reliver out of the Yankees’ pen. Caminero hit a sac fly into left to bring Simpson home. They weren’t able to get any additional runs, but they were happy to get at least one back.

Quick little add on pic.twitter.com/IT3WpMZcVE

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

Ryan McMahon singled to start the top of the eighth. Jose Caballero then grounded into a double play. The Yankees couldn’t manage to get anyone else on base. In the home half, Brent Headrick was the next reliever out. He gave up a leadoff single to Jake Fraley. A sac bunt from Mullins did exactly what it was meant to, getting Fraley to second. A pinch-hitting Ben Williamson came on, singling, and getting Fraley over to third. Walls then came up to put down the second bunt of the inning, it was ruled a fielder’s choice as Fraley got home and everyone else was safe on base. A double play then ended the inning, but the Rays had regained their three-run lead.

High 👋! pic.twitter.com/6s2d9mmnQw

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

Turns out they’d really need that buffer. Mason Englert was the next reliever up for the Rays. Ben Rice singled, followed by an Aaron Judge home run, and suddenly it was back to being a one-run game. Chisholm then hit a ball right down the first base line that Williamson hustled to get over to and got to first in time for the out. With two outs Amed Rosario hit a double out to center that should have been caught by Mullins but it went right over his head, literally. I am now reminded, as well, that while it’s nice to play games at the Trop, playing against the Yankees at the Trop is the worst because of the crowd noise. Austin Wells was intentionally walked to put two on. The gambit paid off as McMahon grounded out to end the inning and the Rays held onto their lead, just barely, to sweep the series.

Final: Rays 5, Yankees 4