Cowboys' search for solution to this key role is perfect as is, for now

Long-term, most people likely think of rookie draft pick Caleb Downs. A highly-touted defensive back from Ohio State, Downs is known as a football savant. He’s wowed coaches with his football acumen throughout his collegiate career and has lived up to his big-brained reputation since joining the Cowboys in April. But Downs is a rookie, and as such, might not be the optimal solution right out of the gate.

Schottenheimer mentioned a different safety who makes plenty of sense in Thompson. Thompson was Dallas’ top hire in free agency and joins the Cowboys with a wealth of knowledge in regard to scheme. He’s similar to Downs in preparedness and versatility and could very easily handle the responsibilities of the green dot on Day 1.

Overshown and Winters, the two linebackers Schottenheimer mentioned, are distinct possibilities as well. Given the position they play, they may even be early favorites to capture the role. Most green dots are worn by linebackers and these two 25-year-olds each have a track record of success under their belts. Since there isn’t a clearcut solution on staff, Schottenheimer seems comfortable making it an open competition this summer. In his own words, “there will be trial and error” to determine a solution.

“That’ll be new,” Winters said of getting the green dot. “But there’s a first time for every time and I’m willing to do whatever it takes.”

Ideally, Dallas would have a proven veteran to take over the spot on the first day of training camp. He’d be well acquainted with Parker’s defense, he’d understand the strengths and weakness of the Cowboys' roster, and he’d have skins on the wall to prove he's up to the task. But rarely are things ideal when we’re discussing the 32nd-ranked defense from last year. Growing pains are needed and trial and error are necessary. What works as solution in Week 1 is not automatically the same solution in Week 18.

The benefits of this open competition are clear, as it puts multiple players in a leadership role going into camp. The more players who prepare for the green dot, the better. Not only does it make the roster smarter, but it makes it more adaptable to injuries down the road.

The Cowboys don’t have an answer for the green dot. They don’t need an answer for the green dot. Not yet at least.

You can follow Reid on X @ReidDHanson and be sure to follow Cowboys Wire on Facebook to join in on the conversation with fellow fans!

This article originally appeared on Cowboys Wire: Cowboys green dot conundrum: Competition vs clear cut solution