Dallas Cowboys can make the perfect trade offer for standout NFL edge rusher while keeping two first-round picks

Despite missing four games last season, Highsmith finished the season with 9.5 sacks and 44 quarterback pressures. Pro Football Focus graded him as a Top 15 edge rusher in the NFL.

My Cowboys offer for Highsmith

I don’t expect Highsmith to be a cheap get for multiple reasons. First, at 28 years old, he’s high-caliber play isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. Secondly, he’s already under contract for the next two seasons. Lastly, if the Steelers indeed shop him around, the Cowboys won’t be the only ones picking up the phone.

So I’m aiming for value similar to a second-round pick for Pittsburgh. Here’s how Dallas gets there:

• Steelers get: pick No. 12 overall (first round), pick No. 92 overall (third round)
• Cowboys get: OLB Alex Highsmith, pick No. 21 overall (first round), pick No. 161 overall (fifth round)

Per the Rich Hill trade chart, the above compensation is the equivalent to a middle round second-round pick.

The Cowboys would pick back-to-back at No. 20 and 21 while landing a significant upgrade at edge rusher that screams scheme fit for Parker. Losing No. 92 hurts, but Dallas won’t find a starter that deep in the third round.

For a better understanding of how the Steelers would feel about the offer, I reached out to our own Rob Gregson from A to Z Sports Pittsburgh.

Steelers take

You know it's NFL Draft week when the pre-draft rumors of trades start flying, and one of the best pass rushers in recent Steelers memory is at the forefront.

At the surface level, you see an EDGE rotation that looks crowded with the likes of T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith, Nick Herbig and Jack Sawyer. That's true to a certain extent, but the Steelers rotate their pass rushers a ton. Maybe that changes under Pat Graham.

But from Highsmith's perspective, he was the most productive pass rusher on the team in 2025. He's firmly entrenched in his prime, and unlike Herbig, he's an every down player as someone who is stout against the run.

For the Steelers to truly consider trading Highsmith, it's gotta be a serious offer. One like this one from the Cowboys. I would imagine Khan and Co. would think long and hard about a that level of capital, and it may be too good of an offer to refuse. – Rob Gregson