Drew Allar could be the biggest steal of the 2026 NFL Draft

Allar may justify that gamble. His draft position presents moderate risk, but his upside offers significant reward.

Many of Allar’s flaws stem from his raw development as a passer. His mechanics—especially his footwork—remain underdeveloped, leading to inconsistent accuracy. However, refining those issues is exactly what McCarthy was hired to do.

Allar’s upside becomes clear on film. He possesses a powerful arm, impressive pocket movement, and prototypical size for the position.

MORE: 5 best NFL signings of undrafted players following 2026 Draft

McCarthy faces a significant challenge. Allar’s draft stock once projected him as a top-five pick before it fell into the late-third to early-fifth round range.

His talent alone once placed him among the top prospects. Now the question is whether McCarthy can unlock that potential.

Allar will have a strong supporting cast in Pittsburgh. The receiving corps has been retooled, the team features two standout tight ends, the offensive line continues to improve, and the backfield remains deep.

If Rodgers returns, Allar will also have the opportunity to develop behind one of the NFL’s all-time greats. Still, expectations should remain measured; Allar is not guaranteed to become the future of the franchise.

However, if the Steelers’ gamble on McCarthy pays off, it will likely do so through Allar emerging as the team’s long-term answer at quarterback.