Emilio Pagán is only a little bit hurt

CINCINNATI, OHIO - APRIL 14: Emilio Pagán #15 of the Cincinnati Reds throws a pitch during the ninth inning against the San Francisco Giants at Great American Ball Park on April 14, 2026 in Cincinnati, Ohio. (Photo by Justin Casterline/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Cincinnati Reds closer Emilio Pagán picked up his 5th save of the 2026 season on Tuesday night, coaxing a deep fly-out off the bat of San Francisco Giants pinch hitter Daniel Susac to help wrap up a closely fought 2-1 victory.

That was obviously the good news. The bad news – or potentially bad news, at least – was that he clearly seemed to grimace while delivering the pitch. Since it coincided with the end of the game, coverage of said grimace was a bit scant, and we were instead left waiting to find out just exactly what happened.

Was it a knee? Was it something innocuous?

According to MLB.com’s Mark Sheldon, it’s a hamstring issue for Pagán, one that comes with a bit of optimism about the recovery time needed.

Sheldon later clarified that it’s his left hamstring, not right.

The Reds have already announced a starting lineup for Wednesday’s game against the Giants, and they’ve made no roster moves in concurrence with said lineup. So, it’s safe to say that Pagán isn’t going to need a trip to the IL to get this right – at least, not yet.

My best guess is that they’ll slow-play this and hope it improves significantly with a day or two of rest, and that he’ll be unavailable to pitch while that’s going on. That would open up potential save opportunities elsewhere in the bullpen, something both Connor Phillips and Brock Burke have taken advantage of already in the early portions of this season.

If things don’t improve quickly, though, we could see a backdated move to the IL for Pagán. The problem there, though, is that there isn’t a clear replacement for his services in AAA. Zach Maxwell has a save and is on the roster, but he’s struggled mightily in his first 7 games of the year. Both Tejay Antone and Lyon Richardson have ample experience and are pitching well, but neither currently holds a spot on the 40-man roster. Luis Mey would probably end up getting the call, as he’s allowed just 2 ER in 6.0 IP with an 8/2 K/BB, though he has also yielded 3 unearned runs to date.

For now, we’ll hedge that Pagán truly did ‘dodge a bullet’ and that this will be a non-story in short order. Of course, it would be nice if the Reds offense would actually score enough runs to make ‘needing a closer in 1-run games every single day’ less of an importance for a change, too.