Foundational Fatigue: Can the 49ers Find Their Next Wave of All-Pros in the 2026 Draft?

Foundational Fatigue: Can the 49ers Find Their Next Wave of All-Pros in the 2026 Draft?

The San Francisco 49ers have a list of boxes they’ll need to check when making their selections in the 2026 NFL Draft.

While their list of needs is clearly topped by the defensive end and wide receiver positions, there’s a larger need that stands out, pushing typical positional assignments into the background. Above all else, the 49ers need to find stars, regardless of what position they play.

The Aging Core and the Star Vacuum

San Francisco’s Super Bowl window has been propped open for years by cornerstone players like George Kittle, Fred Warner, Kyle Juszczyk, and Nick Bosa. It received additional support with the arrival of Trent Williams in 2020 and Christian McCaffrey in 2022.

However, as Father Time starts to descend on that core group, the front office has yet to bring in adequate star caliber talent to prop a new window once the current core ages out. While Brock Purdy is firmly established as the franchise quarterback, the surrounding landscape is shifting. The fractured relationship with Brandon Aiyuk, uncertainty surrounding Mykel Williams following a rookie ACL tear, and Ricky Pearsall’s injury woes leave the club’s long term contention in doubt.

Stars Win Titles

Surrounding Purdy with top level talent is the best way to compete for a championship. While San Francisco has added several "contributors" lately, stars are the ones who truly move the needle. For these purposes, we define a "star" by Pro Bowl and All-Pro nods.

The 49ers' drafting history tells a tale of two eras:

• 2017–2019: The 49ers selected four foundational players (Kittle, Warner, Bosa, and Deebo Samuel) who each made at least one Pro Bowl and one All-Pro team. This was the bedrock of their current window.
• 2020–2025: Success has been much harder to find. In that six year span, the 49ers selected only two players (Purdy and Talanoa Hufanga) who earned Pro Bowl nods. Hufanga is the only player in that group to make an All-Pro team (2022), and the team let him walk in free agency three years later.

Positional Need vs. Replenishing Power

There is an immediate necessity at DE and WR, and a significant need is brewing at both offensive tackle spots. If the team is simply trying to maximize the roster around the current, aging core, then grabbing a player who fills a positional need is the priority.

On the other hand, if the 49ers are focused on building out their future roster, they may want to put positions aside in lieu of a quest to replenish the star power on their roster. Doing so may not be the most efficient move for the 2026 season, but it could pay massive dividends down the road as the 2019 core eventually departs.