Inside the decisions, penalties and controversies that defined Arsenal’s draw with Atletico

Makkelie blew the whistle and pointed to the penalty spot as the protestations begin from the Atletico Madrid players and supporters. VAR checked the incident but decided to stick with the on-field decision and Gyokeres drove the resultant spot kick into the bottom left corner.

Viktor Gyokeres was fouled by David Hancko for the first penalty decision (Getty)

55th minute - Ben White’s handball

In pursuit of an equaliser, Atletico stepped up a gear at the start of the second half and pushed higher up the pitch. Marcos Llorente received the ball just outside the Arsenal box and took a shot which wasn’t heading on target.

Arsenal defender Ben White blocks the effort and immediately comes the cries from the Atletico players who are convinced he handled the ball. The referee initially waves away the appeals but VAR intervenes and calls Makkelie to the pitchside monitor.

White’s left hand is away from his body and the ball clearly strikes it. In the Champions League these incidents have been given all season and the same happened here, with the referee overturning his initial decision, despite a dispute that ball bounced up off White’s leg before striking his hand.

Julian Alvarez took the resultant penalty and blasted it past David Raya to score the equaliser.

Marcos Llorente's wayward shot struck Ben White's hand resulting in a penalty after a VAR check (PA)

78th minute - Eberechi Eze fouled by David Hancko

Perhaps the most controversial moment of the evening as Bukayo Saka feeds the ball into the right side of the Atletico box. Eberechi Eze, fresh off the bench, stretched to beat Hancko to the ball and gets clipped on the foot by the defender. Eze goes down and is awarded a penalty by Makkelie before the game is paused for another VAR check.

82nd minute - Arsenal’s penalty is overturned

Following a lengthy check by the VAR, Makkelie is once again called over to the pitchside monitor as Atletico Madrid’s manager, Diego Simone riles up the crowd and challenges the fourth official on the sidelines. Makkelie takes 45 seconds to watch the incident 13 times before deciding that the contact between Hancko and Eze isn’t enough to cause a spot kick.

He reverses his decision again and Arsenal lose the chance to retake the lead late in the game.

Eberechi Eze was clipped by Hancko inside the Atletico box but the on-field penalty decision was overturned after another VAR intervention (AP)

Post match reaction

Needless to say the incidents proved to be the biggest talking points of the game and TNT Sports pundits Steven Gerrard, Steve McManaman and Martin Keown were perplexed at the decisions made.

“I don’t think it was clear and obvious and the referee should be allowed to referee the game,” said Keown before adding: “VAR’s got too involved... the referee I felt in the end buckled under the pressure.”

Gerrard agreed and said: “I’m surprised he got sent to the screen. I think there’s minimal contact but it’s really harsh on Arsenal to overturn that because it’s not clear and obvious.”

McManaman’s reaction was perhaps the most telling in summing up the feeling of the watching fans as he said: “We’re talking about VAR again, I hate it. It spoils the game. Once he gives it and there’s contact it’s not a clear and obvious error. You shouldn’t go back and re-ref it again. It baffles me.”