Is the Astros’ Championship Window Really Open?

A Pitching Staff in Crisis

Coming into the season, general manager Dana Brown and the organization emphasized their depth in starting pitching. It was supposed to be a strength. Instead, just a few weeks into the season, it’s become the team’s biggest liability. Injuries have piled up. Roles are uncertain. And on a nightly basis, the question looms: who’s going to take the mound next, and can they give this team a chance to win? That’s a massive problem for a team with legitimate postseason aspirations.

Missed Evaluations and Mounting Pressure

This all circles back to roster construction. Brown, now in the final year of his contract, is under increasing pressure. Whether or not ownership has limited his ability to make moves, the reality is that the results haven’t been good enough. The pitching staff, a strength just a year ago, has regressed in alarming fashion. Yes, some players overachieved last season and some are failing miserbly this season. But more importantly, the Astros had a staff in 2025 that could get outs, limit damage, and hold leads, and now it seems the team got a little too flipped constructing the pen and may have taken for granted how difficult a task it can be.

Bullpen Breakdown

The bullpen, has been a recurring issue and a massive disappointment. Bryan Abreu has been almost unusable. With Josh Hader out, this has been the absolute worst case scenario. Too many walks. Too many pitches thrown. Too many situations where a lead feels anything but safe. It’s a dangerous combination. The few guys who can get outs are being used far too often, like Bryan King last night. Putting runners on base, especially without forcing hitters to earn it sets the table for tragedy. It’s all a recipe for disaster, and right now it feels like every inning comes with traffic on the bases and chance to fail yet again.

Rotation Questions and Failed Solutions

The problems extend beyond the bullpen, because the starting rotation has been just as bad. The Astros knew changes were coming to the rotation. They knew they would have to replace key arms and find reliable options. Instead, the solutions they’ve turned to, both domestically and internationally, haven’t delivered. Tatsuya Imai, for example, has been a major disappointment. Whether it’s injuries, adjustment issues, or a lack of proper evaluation before bringing him in, the result has been the same: he hasn’t helped stabilize the rotation. Meanwhile, potential external solutions are disappearing. Pitchers like Lucas Giolito, now signed with the San Diego Padres, are no longer options, raising further questions about whether Crane is willing to spend what it takes to fix the problem and IF Dana Brown is the man to get it done.

A Staff Running on Empty

Another concern is the workload being placed on the few reliable arms this team does have. The pitchers who are performing are being asked to do too much, throw too many pitches, cover too many innings, and compensate for those who can’t carry their share of the load. That’s not sustainable over a full season. And if those arms start to wear down, things could go from bad to worse in a hurry.

What Comes Next?

This brings us back to the original question: what does an “open window” really mean? Because right now, this doesn’t look like a team built to contend, it looks like a team with a glaring weakness that hasn’t been addressed. There’s still time. The trade deadline offers an opportunity. Reinforcements could come in the form of returning arms like Hunter Brown, and perhaps even Christian Javier down the line. But hope alone isn’t a strategy.

The Bottom Line

This is not the time to wave the white flag or consider moving key pieces. It’s the time to double down, to identify the problem and fix it. The offense has already proven it can carry its weight. Now it’s up to the front office to give this team the pitching it desperately needs. If Jim Crane truly believes the window is always open, then the next move is clear: Do something to keep it that way.