It’s time to make Quenton Nelson a Colt for life

At the time it was signed, it reset the guard market. Looking back now, it’s arguably a bargain given his level of play and how the market has continued to rise.

He’s entering the final year of that contract with a cap hit of $24.2 million in 2026. If the Colts do nothing, he would hit free agency in 2027 as an unrestricted free agent.

And he wouldn’t just be another name on the market. He would be one of the premier players available at any position. That’s not a situation the Colts should be comfortable letting play out.

Projecting his next contract

The guard market has continued to climb, and Nelson should be right at the top of it again.

Right now, Tyler Smith leads the way at $24 million per year with $81 million guaranteed over four years. Trey Smith is just behind at $23.5 million per year with $70 million guaranteed. Luke Goedeke sits at $22.5 million annually, and Landon Dickerson is at $21 million per years over 4 years with $50 guaranteed..

Nelson belongs above all of them. Not just because of past production, but because of sustained elite play over time. He has been more consistent, more durable, more proven than any of those players and as mentioned above, he is still in the middle of his prime.

With the salary cap increasing by roughly 7 percent per year, a new deal should reflect that growth. If you apply that increase to the current top of the market, Nelson’s number naturally pushes into the mid-$25 million range annually.

A realistic projection looks like this:

Four years, $103 million total ($25.75 million per year) with $77 million guaranteed

That structure keeps him at the top of the market while aligning with how recent deals have been built. Four years remains the standard, and roughly 75 percent guaranteed fits with the upper tier of contracts at the position. More importantly, it locks in one of your core players through the remainder of his prime.

Don’t let this drag out!!

The Colts just went through a messy process with Alec Pierce, where waiting created unnecessary complications and there’s no reason to repeat that here.

Nelson’s value is stable. You know exactly what he is as a player. But the longer you wait, the more variables you introduce. One down year can change the conversation. Free agency always brings risk. And once a player gets that close to the open market, decisions become less predictable.

This is one of those situations where you act early and avoid all of that. Don’t mess around with Quenton Nelson!

He has earned everything he’s made with this team, and this next contract should reflect both his production and his importance to the organization. It’s not a thank-you deal as he’s still one of the best guards in football. But if the Colts want to reward their own and build stability into the roster, this is where it starts.

Make him a Colt for life!