Jets face key decision at No. 2 between Bailey and Reese

Photo by CFP/Getty Images

Reports suggest the New York Jets are still deciding between David Bailey and Arvell Reese with the No. 2 pick, and the fact that it remains unsettled is what stands out. Bailey recorded 14.5 sacks, 19.5 tackles for loss, and had one of the highest pressure rates among recent draft prospects.

Reese offers real physical upside — he ran a 4.46 forty at over 240 pounds — but doesn’t have nearly the same pass-rush production or polish. These aren’t two similar prospects; one is a finished pass rusher, and the other is a raw athlete still learning the position. It shouldn’t be as close as it seems.

Bailey is a day-one starter who offers more than just traits

Bailey’s résumé speaks for itself. His 14.5 sacks and 19.5 tackles for loss last season aren’t just eye-catching numbers—they reflect a well-rounded, highly productive player whose game is already polished.

This isn’t a case of betting on traits and waiting for things to click. It’s about picking someone who’s already shown he can produce at the top level of college football and expecting that impact to carry over quickly.

Reese’s athleticism stands out, but Bailey is the more complete pass rusher

Reese brings more speed and versatility, there’s no question. A 4.46 at his size stands out, and his ability to play multiple roles offers something unique. He has a rare blend of traits that can’t be ignored.

But as a pure pass rusher, he’s still raw. Splitting time between edge and off-ball linebacker means he doesn’t have the same volume of reps or consistency in his rush plan that Bailey does. That profile makes sense in the middle of the first round where there’s time to develop him, but it looks riskier at No. 2 when someone as polished as Bailey is still available.

Top Draft picks usually don’t look this unsettled

Right now, Bailey is the slight favourite, but Reese is still getting plenty of consideration. Uncertainty like this so close to draft day isn’t typical for a top-two pick. Teams picking that high usually have their minds made up well before now, and when they don’t, those picks often become the subject of long-term debate.

Back in 2022, Jacksonville went through something similar. The Jaguars chose Travon Walker over Aidan Hutchinson, despite Walker having the physical tools and Hutchinson coming off a productive college career. Hutchinson made an immediate impact in the league, and the decision quickly became a talking point around Jacksonville.