Knicks lose, Mets blow 4-run lead and Jets make much-criticized NFL Draft selection in wild 4 minutes for New York sports

Thursday was a big night for New York sports.

The New York Knicks had a playoff game. The New York Mets were trying to put together a winning streak. The New York Jets and Giants both had selections to make in the 2026 NFL Draft. And the New York Yankees were facing their rival Boston Red Sox.

The latter event well enough, with Cam Schlittler outdueling rookie Payton Tolle in a 4-2 win. The Giants also did well enough, landing Ohio State linebacker Arvell Reese and Miami offensive tackle Francis Mauigoa in the top 10.

The rest, well, let’s just say the city had a very bad 10 minutes. Here is a tweet from The Ringer’s Sean Fennessey summing up the stakes at 9:42 p.m. ET:

Then, four minutes later:

So we have some unpacking to do.

Let’s go first to the Knicks, who entered Thursday in dire need of a win in Game 3 of their first-round series against the Atlanta Hawks. They had a one-point lead with 16.4 seconds to go, and then C.J. McCollum happened:

And then this happened, sealing a 2-1 series deficit for New York against its recent antagonist:

Then there were the Mets, who recently snapped a 12-game losing streak, their worst since 2002. In the following game, they were up 7-3 against the Minnesota Twins with Huascar Brazobán on the mound in the eighth inning. With the bases loaded.

Cue Ryan Jeffers.

That grand slam tied the game and continued the Mets’ significant bullpen issues to begin the season, but all was not lost. The Mets responded by loading the bases in the bottom of the eighth, setting up a three-run double from Bo Bichette to re-take the lead in what ended up being a 10-8 win.

And then there were the Jets, who had the No. 16 pick in draft and plenty of holes to fill after selecting edge rusher David Bailey with the second pick.