Maldini’s ghost hangs over uninspiring Milan as top-four place slips from view | Nicky Bandini

The appointment of Massimiliano Allegri this summer was supposed to get things back on track. Here was a man defined by Italy’s sporting press as a “guarantee” of Champions League football.

An aggressive summer transfer window followed, headlined by the arrival of Luka Modric, and featuring significant outlays on the likes of Christopher Nkunku, Ardon Jashari, Samuele Ricci, Koni De Winter, Adrien Rabiot and Pervis Estupiñán. With no European distractions, Milan looked well equipped for a strong domestic campaign.

Massimiliano Allegri was brought in to bring Champions League football back to Milan. Photograph: Image Photo Agency/Getty Images

Up until March, they produced one. The performance to beat Inter was classic Allegri, controlling the game while surrendering possession. Estupiñán scored before half-time, and Milan barely gave their opponents a sniff after that. This had been the mode all season: just win, it does not need to be pretty.

But the problem with focusing always on the outcome is that you have nothing to fall back on once that part goes wrong. Milan’s form early this season was built on the performances of talented individuals – Modric, certainly, but also Rabiot and especially Christian Pulisic, who had eight goals and two assists in the league, despite missing five games, by the end of December.

Allegri’s innovation was to move the American inside to operate as a centre-forward. He pulled the same trick with Rafael Leão after the Portuguese returned from a calf injury. Both thrived at first, but as their goals tailed off, Milan have struggled to replace them.

Too many square pegs forced into round holes? Or is the picture a little more nuanced? Both Pulisic and Leão have been affected by physical issues as the season progressed. The former was supposed to start against Atalanta, before being ruled out at the last moment with a glute complaint. Leão played but continued to look a shadow of his best self, failing to beat his man on four out of five attempted dribbles.

Atalanta were excellent, pressing selectively and executing ruthlessly. Giacomo Raspadori, signed from Atlético Madrid in January, brought a typically high-energy bustle behind the attack and it was his blocked shot that rebounded to Éderson inside the box for the opener. Nikola Krstovic, in the No 9 role, pinned his man expertly before laying the ball off to Davide Zappacosta to make it 2-0 before half-time.

What stood out in these moments was the clarity of purpose: each player performing the role they are best suited to and understanding what was required. The contrast with Milan’s disjointed assembly of talents was stark. Absent the injured Modric, there was no glue to bind them together.

Raspadori made it 3-0 at the start of the second half, beating Mike Maignan at his near post. San Siro began to empty. Reporters saw a pair of fans attempt a protest, holding up shirts with Maldini’s name on the back in front of the section where executives sit, but stewards ushered them away.

Ultras had already made their feelings known before kick-off with a protest outside the ground then a choreography in the Curva Sud, using their bodies and mobile phone flashlights to spell out the letters “G.F. OUT” – Furlani’s initials.

By leaving early, they almost missed an improbable turnaround. Milan pulled a goal back in the 88th minute, Strahinja Pavlovic heading home from a Ricci free-kick. Nkunku, on as a second-half substitute, then won and converted a penalty. Suddenly the deficit was down to one goal. In the seventh minute of injury time, Matteo Gabbia almost equalised, flashing a header wide from another set-piece.

Milan fans use their mobile phone flashlights to protest against Giorgio Furlani.
Photograph: Daniele Mascolo/Reuters

The game ended 3-2 to Atalanta, a result that felt misleading. Milan had almost pinched a draw, but only because their opponents got complacent. There was little here to encourage belief in better times just around the corner.

For now, they are clinging on to fourth spot, but only by virtue of their head-to-head tiebreaker over Roma, who have drawn level on 67 points. Como are only two further back. It is also true that neither third-placed Juventus, on 68 nor even second-placed Napoli, on 70, have locked down their spots just yet.

On paper, Milan’s final two games look very winnable, against opponents from the bottom half. But Genoa, next up, have been anything but a pushover since hiring Daniele De Rossi as manager in November.

More to the point, Milan simply have not been good enough in the last two months to feel confident in their ability to beat anyone. After their previous game, a 2-0 loss at Sassuolo, Allegri told reporters: “I always said I would be happy to secure Champions League football even on the final weekend”. It looks unlikely now to come any sooner, if it arrives at all.