Newcastle United And Eddie Howe Are In A Tragic Bind

"There are so many moving parts with it for him. If all things are equal, then yes, I would like him to [stay]. But does he feel as if he is going to have the chance? Does he want to do it again? Are Newcastle going to have to sell?

"If he has money to spend and he doesn’t have to sell, then, yeah. But I looked at the players yesterday, and if that was what they call fighting for their manager, because he is under huge pressure, whether you like it or not, they were terrible. They chucked him under the bus, the players. The performance was c**p from every single one of them.

"It is a tough situation, a tough summer for Newcastle coming up. They have got some big decisions to make. As I am sat here, I don’t see Eddie in charge of Newcastle next season, unfortunately.”

Once a manager’s motivation has seeped away—a point which is difficult to confirm—it’s tough to recover. This challenge is relevant now as the club faces mounting struggles.

Recent results for Newcastle have been dire, but it might not be because the coach has lost the love.

NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE, ENGLAND - APRIL 18: Eddie Howe, Manager of Newcastle United, applauds the fans after the Premier League match between Newcastle United and Bournemouth at St James' Park on April 18, 2026 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

Getty Images

Nevertheless, even the loyal North East fanbase is starting to wonder what life might be without Howe, according to Sky Sports News reporter Keith Downie.

"The situation has not changed since the Bournemouth game but it feels like it’s about 50-50 within the fanbase as to whether they want Eddie Howe to remain in charge,” he claimed.

"Is that uncertainty feeding into the poor performances and the general negative mood? Potentially yes. This isn’t the Newcastle we've seen under the last couple of years, the swashbuckling style.

"It feels like some players have checked out, to an extent. Four defeats in a row, eight defeats from 11, and at St James’ Park which has previously been a fortress, five out of the last six matches have ended in defeat.

"I don’t think PIF [the club's owners] will make any knee-jerk reactions. They'll look at the situation at the end of the season, but so will Howe himself and question whether he is ready to go again.

"There is a question over whether he will stay at the club in the longer term, but we won’t get an answer to that question until the end of the season.

"The last one did not go well after spending £250m in the summer, and three out of the five big-money arrivals have not worked.

"Howe has to wear that, he didn’t get his first-choice signings but they were all players still on his list. He was asked a direct question about that a few weeks ago and confirmed that.

"But looking at the big-name stars, Sandro Tonali and Anthony Gordon, who have both been at the centre of speculation about their futures, they’re guys who are going to look to move elsewhere if their ambitions don't feel matched by Newcastle.”

Though these issues are beyond Howe’s control, he must navigate them because there is no alternative leadership.

From the lack of progress in developing the stadium and training ground to the unedifying transfer saga involving Alexander Isak in the summer, Howe is the man who faces the questions.

Now the counterargument would be that this is what any manager at an elite club should expect.

But the brutal reality is that Newcastle United is not there yet, and therefore it is totally unfair to cast such a judgment.

As summer nears, the two parties must decide: commit to one final effort together, or choose to replace leadership and inject new energy into the dugout?

Newcastle’s task will remain steep, and Howe must now confront whether he still has the resolve for a challenge defined by outsized expectations and unstable foundations.​

This article was originally published on Forbes.com