NFL draft odds: Jets can go several directions with No. 2 pick after Raiders take Fernando Mendoza at No. 1

Reese is the favorite after emerging as Ohio State's standout playmaker on a loaded defensive unit for the Buckeyes. He didn't have the most eye-popping numbers, but he showed out against the toughest competition, racking up nine tackles and a sack against Texas to open the season. He added nine tackles and 1.5 sacks against Illinois, 12 tackles and a sack against Penn State and seven tackles in the College Football Playoff matchup with Miami. He'd be a foundational player for the Jets to rebuild their defense around.

New York could also go with Bailey, who exploded as a sack machine in his lone season in Lubbock after steadily improving in three seasons at Stanford. He entered the 2025 campaign with 14.5 sacks across three seasons with the Cardinal and then racked up 14.5 sacks with Texas Tech en route to a Big 12 championship and CFP berth. The Jets struggled to rush the passer and subsequently, force turnovers. Bailey could immediately change that, though Reese might have more staying power at his position.

Bet on the Jets to take Arvell Reese or David Bailey with the latest BetMGM promo code.

Of the longshots, Simpson probably has the highest likelihood of being taken if the Jets really want to address the quarterback position. They've brought Geno Smith back as a placeholder with an eye on the 2027 draft class, but this is an organization that has been known to make rash decisions routinely. I don't see the Jets pushing for a receiver or running back, but Simpson could be the prospect who makes them abandon their plans. They also have the No. 16 pick, and there's a good possibility Simpson is still available when they're back on the clock.

It's between Reese and Bailey, according to the oddsmakers, and most mock draft experts would likely agree with that thinking. Mike Renner's latest mock draft at CBS Sports has the Jets going with Bailey, but I'll be different and say they take Reese to serve as the anchor for their defense.