Oilers D-man Evan Bouchard ‘upset’ over Norris Trophy snub

Edmonton Oilers defenseman Evan Bouchard (2) skates in the 2026 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Honda Center

Historically, a 95-point season from a defenseman almost guarantees a Norris nomination. In most years, it likely wins the award outright.

This year was different because voters looked beyond raw production.

Makar (79 points) anchored the league’s top penalty kill and drove a Presidents’ Trophy-winning team. Dahlin (74 points) transformed the Buffalo Sabres into a division champion. Werenski (81 points) carried massive minutes for the Columbus Blue Jackets while leading their offense from the back end.

Bouchard admitted the competition, saying, “There’s a lot of great defensemen in the league, so it’s kinda hard to pick between three of them.”

Bouchard’s challenges have also played a role, since the Oilers regressed badly defensively all season. Edmonton finished 25th in goals against, struggled on the penalty kill, and often looked disconnected structurally in its own zone.

MORE: Oilers need Penguins-style support system for Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl

Fair or not, Norris voting still rewards two-way impact. Bouchard’s offensive generation was elite, but his defensive game remained polarizing around the league, paired with the Oilers’ struggles.

Edmonton’s bigger issues hurt his candidacy

The Oilers’ first-round 4-2 exit against the Anaheim Ducks likely reinforced existing concerns among voters.

Bouchard posted seven playoff points, but he also finished with a minus-7 rating during a series where Edmonton repeatedly lost defensive coverage battles. The Oilers surrendered eight power-play goals in six games and blew multiple leads after scoring first.

That matters because perception often shapes award races. When a team collapses defensively, its top-pair defenseman usually absorbs part of the blame.

MORE: NHL analyst warns Connor McDavid could leave Oilers to chase Stanley Cup

Still, Bouchard’s frustration is understandable. At 26, he remains one of hockey’s premier puck-moving defensemen and arguably the league’s most dangerous power-play quarterback outside Makar.