Oilers urged to avoid panic move involving $74M D-man after early playoff exit

There is no denying Nurse’s $74 million contract remains difficult to justify against his recent production. The veteran defenseman carries a $9.25 million cap hit through 2030 and finished the regular season with only 24 points and a minus-12 rating.

Still, Edmonton’s defensive issues extend well beyond one player.

MORE: Former NHL goalie Devan Dubnyk flags major issue in Oilers’ goaltending setup

The Oilers ranked 25th in goals against (3.23) during the regular season and never established defensive consistency despite elite offensive production from Connor McDavid (138 points) and Leon Draisaitl (97 points). Their penalty kill also collapsed in the playoffs, operating at just 50% against Anaheim.

Nurse remains one of the few defenders on the roster capable of handling heavy minutes against top competition. Even during a down year, he averaged nearly 19 minutes at five-on-five and continued facing difficult matchup assignments nightly.

That workload matters. Top-four defensemen with size, skating ability, and durability are difficult to replace, especially for teams operating near the salary cap.

Oilers must avoid emotional roster decisions

Gregor’s larger point reflects a reality many playoff disappointments expose. Teams often mistake visibility for responsibility. Nurse’s contract makes him the easiest target, but removing him without securing a legitimate replacement could weaken Edmonton further.

“So if you’re gonna trade Nurse, it’s gotta be for a player that’s gonna play 19-plus minutes, right?” Gregor said. “Different player, fine, but that’s what it has to be. You can’t just give him away, then you’re searching.”

That is the key distinction.

The Oilers still possess enough star power to remain contenders, but their roster construction requires balance. Jake Walman’s health remains uncertain, the defensive depth lacks stability, and the organization still needs more reliable penalty killing.

MORE: NHL analyst warns Connor McDavid could leave Oilers to chase Stanley Cup

Edmonton’s offseason should focus on improving structure and defensive support around its core, not making reactionary moves after one disappointing playoff run.