Report: Chelsea and Man United in a race to sign €60m-rated midfielder

Photo: IMAGO

Caught Offside note that “His confidence on the ball, sharp football intelligence, and ability to control matches from midfield have caught the attention of scouts across the continent.” That description alone explains the €60m-€80m valuation.

Jorge Mendes Influence Raises Stakes

The involvement of Jorge Mendes changes the tone entirely. Deals attached to his name tend to escalate quickly, both in scale and expectation. Caught Offside highlight that his presence “usually signals a deal of significant scale”, and that feels particularly true here.

AZ Alkmaar hold a strong hand. With Smit contracted until 2029, there is no urgency to sell. The reported fee would break Dutch transfer records, a reflection of both confidence and strategy.

Premier League Clubs Lead The Race

Chelsea and Manchester United appear at the front of the queue, though with different motivations. Chelsea view Smit as a long-term investment, a player to mould. United’s interest feels more immediate, tied to a broader midfield rebuild.

Other clubs hover in the background. Arsenal and Liverpool appreciate technical midfielders, while Barcelona and Borussia Dortmund represent alternative pathways. Each option offers a different kind of development, and that choice may ultimately define Smit’s career.

For now, the story remains unresolved, but the direction is clear. Smit is no longer a prospect hidden in the Eredivisie, he is a name shaping the next transfer window.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

From a Manchester United perspective, this report raises more questions than it answers. Smit sounds like the right profile, young, technically secure, and comfortable dictating play, but United’s recent recruitment suggests caution is needed.

There is a temptation to see a €60m-€80m midfielder and assume instant transformation, yet United’s issues in midfield run deeper than individual talent. Structure, balance, and coaching remain central concerns. As one fan might argue, “We have signed potential before, but without a clear system, potential often stalls.”

Smit could fit into a rebuild, especially if the club commits to a possession based identity. His ability to control tempo would complement more dynamic players around him. However, if the environment remains unstable, the risk increases significantly.

Chelsea’s interest adds another layer. Their model of stockpiling young talent may not guarantee immediate opportunities, but it does provide a clearer developmental pathway in some cases. United, by contrast, often expect young players to perform quickly under pressure.

For supporters, the excitement is understandable. A midfielder capable of shaping games is exactly what the squad lacks. Still, recruitment must align with a broader vision. Without that, even the most promising talent can struggle to fulfil expectations.