Report: Everton set to battle Leeds United in the race to sign Newcastle United defender

There is something quietly persuasive about durability. Thirty six starts this season represents more than availability, it reflects trust. “Targett has started 36 games this season, the highest tally he has managed in a single campaign, and has been a key figure in Boro’s push for promotion from the Championship.”

In a league defined by relentless scheduling and physical demand, that reliability becomes currency. Middlesbrough would prefer to retain him, although “any permanent move is likely to hinge on whether they can secure promotion to the Premier League.” The equation feels simple, remain competitive at the highest level or risk losing a cornerstone.

Meanwhile, Newcastle United appear ready to move on. “With his contract at Newcastle set to expire, Targett is expected to move on from St James’ Park, sparking growing interest from top-flight clubs keen to secure his services on a free transfer.” In modern recruitment, few phrases carry as much intrigue as free transfer.

Everton and Leeds Seek Stability at Left Back

For Everton, the interest feels rooted in necessity. “Everton are believed to be considering a move for Targett, with the Merseyside club prioritising strengthening at left-back this summer.” The uncertainty surrounding Vitaliy Mykolenko, coupled with external interest from Eintracht Frankfurt and RB Leipzig, has left a gap that requires careful planning.

Photo IMAGO

There is also a sense of recalibration. Targett’s profile offers experience without extravagance, reliability without excessive risk. As one might frame it, “Targett’s experience and reliability are seen as valuable assets as David Moyes looks to reshape his squad.” That phrase, reshape, carries weight. It suggests not just change, but direction.

Leeds United approach the situation from a slightly different angle. Depth and adaptability are key considerations. “Leeds, who have tracked Targett previously, remain interested as they assess defensive reinforcements ahead of the new season.” The added dimension is versatility. Targett has operated at centre-back during his time at Middlesbrough, enhancing his appeal.

Photo IMAGO

“A player who can cover for Pascal Struijk in the heart of defence means he could also fit the bill for the Whites.” In a squad where flexibility often dictates selection, that quality may prove decisive.

Versatility and Experience Shape Summer Decision

Beyond England, there are alternative pathways. “Former Aston Villa boss Dean Smith is understood to be keen on a reunion, with the current Charlotte FC manager exploring the prospect of bringing Targett to Major League Soccer.” It is a reminder that careers rarely follow a single trajectory, and that opportunity can present itself in different forms.

For Targett, the decision now revolves around context. Stay within the Premier League, where familiarity meets challenge, or explore a new environment where expectations shift. Each option carries its own rhythm.

In truth, this is less about a headline transfer and more about the quiet mechanics of squad building. Clubs like Everton and Leeds are not chasing spectacle, they are pursuing function. In a market often defined by excess, there is a certain logic in recognising value where others see routine.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

From an Everton perspective, this situation feels like pragmatic business. Supporters have watched inconsistency at left-back become a recurring issue, and the uncertainty around Mykolenko only heightens that concern. A player like Targett offers something dependable, a baseline level that allows the rest of the team to function with greater clarity. Fans may not view it as a transformative signing, yet there is an understanding that stability can be just as valuable as flair.

Leeds supporters will likely frame this differently. There is a recognition that depth often defines survival or success, particularly across a demanding campaign. Targett’s ability to cover multiple roles adds a layer of security that can be decisive over the course of a season. There may also be quiet optimism about what experience can bring to a squad still shaping its identity.

Both fanbases, in their own ways, may see this as a move grounded in logic rather than ambition. That is not necessarily a criticism. In a league where margins are thin, sensible decisions can carry significant weight.