Shohei Ohtani goes seven strong, Dodgers bats go quite again in loss

Ohtani is dealing like a Cy Young contender, yet the Dodgers keep wasting it.

His final line — 7 IP, 4 H, 2 ER, 0 BB, 8 K — his ERA goes up to 0.97. It should have been the headline. Instead, it’s buried under another night where the offense vanished until it was too late.

The only life came in the eighth, when Kyle Tucker poked an RBI single to right to cut the deficit to one. That was it. No sustained pressure. No response to early damage. Just another late, insufficient push.

And here’s where this gets uncomfortable for Dave Roberts.

For the second straight Ohtani start, Roberts opted to use him as a pitcher only, no DH, no bat in the lineup. For the second straight time, the Dodgers lost by one run. Last week, it was against the Miami Marlins. This time, a more respectable opponent, but the same hollow result.

Coincidence? Maybe. But it’s starting to feel like more than that.

Even in the middle of an 0-for-17 slump, Ohtani’s presence changes the shape of a game. Pitchers work differently. Bullpens get leveraged earlier. Mistakes get punished differently. Take that out, and the Dodgers lineup, deep as it is on paper, suddenly looks a lot more ordinary.

Los Angeles Dodgers starting pitcher Shohei Ohtani (17) delivers a pitch during the game against the Houston Astros at Daikin Park.

Maria Lysaker-Imagn Images

Los Angeles Dodgers starting pitcher Shohei Ohtani (17) delivers a pitch during the game against the Houston Astros at Daikin Park.

Ohtani himself didn’t exactly hide his stance last week.

“I think for players who wanna do two-way and if they wanna DH, they should get the option,” he said after that loss to Miami.

Read between the lines, and it wasn’t just a general comment. It was a window into how he views his role, and maybe how this balancing act is affecting him.

Because Ohtani doesn’t just play both ways. He thrives on it. It’s rhythm. It’s identity. It’s part of what makes him different.

And right now, the Dodgers are experimenting with that identity in real time. The results? Mixed at best.

Yes, protecting his workload matters. Yes, it’s early May, not October. But wins in May count the same, and the Dodgers are now 22-14 with a familiar issue: dominant pitching performances getting little to no offensive backing.

So the question isn’t just about strategy. It’s about philosophy.

Do you manage Ohtani like a traditional ace, carefully, conservatively, one role at a time? Or do you lean into what makes him singular, even if it comes with risk?

"If there was a situation where I was hitting well, I'm sure the team would want me to pitch and hit as well,” Ohtani said postgame. “I understand in this situation where just focus on the pitching, turn the page on hitting, I understand that the team might think like that."

Because nights like Tuesday make one thing clear: the “pitcher-only” version of Ohtani might be elite, but it might not be enough,  not for this team, and not the way these games are unfolding.

With the San Francisco Giants waiting next week back at Dodger Stadium, the decision looms again. And it’s no longer just a lineup card choice. It’s a test of whether the Dodgers truly understand the player they built all of this around, or if they’re still trying to fit him into a box he was never meant to occupy.