Supremacy at the Six Nations: is England’s dominance an issue for women’s rugby?

“I think it is about raising the floor without lowering the ceiling. We are trying to keep pushing and pushing that ceiling as high as we can. We are still not happy with certain things we do when we play. We have targets and things to get better at. We want to keep driving that and hopefully other teams will keep driving that as well.”

England are also bringing thousands of fans to the game. Just over 77,000 were at Twickenham in round one of this year’s Women’s Six Nations and they sold out Bristol’s Ashton Gate in round three. There is an argument that crowds follow the Red Roses with just over 21,000 at the Principality Stadium last year for their game against Wales, while the same venue held close to 11,000 for Wales’ fixture against Scotland this year.

However, there are some concerns that England’s dominance could have a negative impact in the longer term. On the BBC’s Rugby Union Weekly podcast, Ugo Monye highlighted that while some fans go to watch women’s rugby for a cheaper family day out and some to see the stars in the teams like Ellie Kildunne, those who want a sporting contest will only be watching “quality rugby from one side”.

Monye also added that if ticket prices rise as women’s rugby becomes more popular, fans may expect more competition on the pitch to keep returning to stadiums.

The gap to England has also not always been as big as the winning run makes it seem, particularly in matches against France. Last year England squeaked a single-point win in a 43-42 thriller at Twickenham, while in 2023 there was another nail-biter at the home of English rugby with the Red Roses able to see out a 38-33 victory.

Close matches against other nations could emerge in years to come with youth games proving more competitive. In the 2026 Under-18s Six Nations Wales beat England 32-24, while France secured a thumping 75-5 win over their rivals. Similar results have happened in the past at youth level but did not translate to the senior international stage. If the unions figure out how to make the jump, the competition will be closer.

And while there is not much jeopardy in games involving England, there is elsewhere in the tournament. So far in the 2026 competition two highly competitive matches standout: Wales’ narrow loss to Scotland in round one and France’s impressive defence holding off Ireland to stop their revenge mission in the most recent matches.

England have had close contests with France in recent years. Photograph: Alastair Grant/AP

Cokayne added: “I am a fan of rugby and we all still get excited watching the different games. Even the France-Wales game was 7-7 at half-time and that was quite interesting to see how that was going to play out. There are some competitive fixtures throughout the whole tournament, the table hasn’t finished the same the last few years.”

The Red Roses are favourites to win the grand slam again this year with only Italy and France standing in the way of their eighth consecutive Six Nations title. This one may be even more impressive though after all of the injuries and absentees they have had to deal with. The forwards coach, Louis Deacon, said when asked how winning the trophy this year would compare to last year’s World Cup win: “It will be as big or even bigger because of the turnover of players.”

So is England’s dominance a problem? Not yet. The sport is growing, crowds are rising and stars are breaking into the mainstream. But if competitiveness fails to keep pace, the question will only grow louder. The burden is not on England to ease off, but on everyone else to close the gap.