Top 5 first basemen in the MLB American League right now

1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

Guerrero proves to be the standard for American League first basemen due to his rare blend of contact hitting and elite power. Despite not leading the league in home runs, his ability to consistently barrel baseballs and drive in runs are evidences to be named as one of the toughest outs in MLB. Toronto’s lineup still revolves around his bat, and his improved defense at first base has elevated him into a complete player rather than simply a slugger. At just 27 years old, Guerrero still appears to be entering the prime years of what could become a Hall of Fame-caliber career.

2. Ben Rice

2. Ben Rice

Rice soars as one of the biggest breakout stars of the 2026 season, giving the Yankees another dangerous left-handed bat alongside Aaron Judge. His offensive numbers have shoo up thanks to a combination of patience, raw power, and improved consistency against elite pitching. What makes his rise even more impressive is how quickly he has become a dependable everyday contributor in New York’s high-pressure environment. Rice looks less like a temporary hot streak and more like the next major star in the Yankees’ lineup.

3. Pete Alonso

3. Pete Alonso

Alonso is still considered as one of the game’s premier power hitters and a constant threat to launch 40-plus home runs in a season. Moving to Baltimore has only increased expectations, especially in a lineup already loaded with offensive firepower. Despite being a defensive liability at times, few players in baseball can match his ability to change a game with one swing. The “Polar Bear” continues to thrive as one of MLB’s most feared middle-of-the-order bats.

RELATED: MLB American League MVP race leaders

4. Nick Kurtz

4. Nick Kurtz

Kurtz revolutionized from a promising young hitter into one of baseball’s most dangerous offensive forces. His rookie campaign showcased massive home-run power, but what truly impressed spectators and analysts is how quickly he has adjusted to major league pitching. The Athletics have built much of their future around his bat, and his presence gives the franchise a legitimate franchise cornerstone moving forward. If his development continues at this pace, Kurtz could soon challenge for the title of best first baseman in all of baseball.

5. Josh Naylor

5. Josh Naylor

Naylor proves to be one of the most underrated first basemen in baseball because of the intensity and versatility he brings every night. Not putting aside his power numbers, he can also provide emotional leadership and surprising athleticism, particularly on the bases for a player of his size. Seattle values his competitive edge as much as his offensive production, and he remains a central piece of the Mariners’ lineup. His all-around impact makes him one of the toughest and most reliable first basemen in the American League today.