Trade up? Trade down? Keep the pick? Rangers have options at No. 5

Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images

Picking fifth, something the Rangers have never done since the draft was instituted in 1963, was the worst possible outcome for the Rangers at the lottery. But that’s not a terrible spot to be in. Nor does it mean they can’t come up with an impact player at that slot.

McKenna is projected to go No. 1 overall, ahead of Sweden forward Ivar Stenberg, who had an excellent season playing against men in the SHL. A strong group of defensemen — lefties Carson Carels and Alberts Smits, and righties Chase Reid, Keaton Verhoeff and Daxon Rudolph — are rated near the top of the draft board. Center Caleb Malhotra, son of former Ranger first-rounder Manny Malhotra (No. 7 overall in 1998) rocketed up the draft ranks late this season. The Rangers need a center, but there’s no guarantee he’ll still be available when they pick.

Malhotra is committed to Boston University (the alma mater of Drury and coach Mike Sullivan), and it’s unclear whether he’d be ready to step into an NHL lineup next season. Another BU center, Tynan Lawrence, also might be an option at No. 5 overall.

The Rangers picked in the top 10 four times since 2017. Forward Alexis Lafreniere (No. 1 overall in 2020) is the only one of the four still with the Rangers. and he never reached 30 goals nor 60 points in six NHL seasons.

Trade up

Russell LaBounty-Imagn Images

If the Rangers decide that the risk of not getting Stenberg, Malhotra, Verhoeff, or Reid is too great to wait for their scheduled pick, Plan B would be to see whether they can make a deal with the Sharks, Canucks or Blackhawks to move up.

The Sharks appear to be the likeliest trade partner. San Jose has a slew of talent up front, headed by 2024 No. 1 pick Macklin Celebrini and including forward Will Smith and center Michael Misa, who went No. 2 in last year’s draft.

But the Sharks didn’t make the Stanley Cup Playoffs this season because of their defensive problems, and lack of a true No. 1 defenseman. A deal between Drury and fellow BU alum Mike Grier, his counterpart in San Jose, could make sense.

In exchange for sending the No. 2 pick to the Rangers, Grier could reasonably expect a package that includes the No. 5 selection, restricted free agent defenseman Braden Schneider (No. 19 overall in 2020) and perhaps the Rangers’ other first-rounder. This lets the Rangers land the player they most covet, and gives the Sharks a young defenseman with NHL experience and the chance to take one of the top-regarded blueliners available in this year’s draft to bolster their D corps.

It’s a big price, but one Drury may want to explore.

Trade down

Jeff Le-Imagn Images

Let’s face it: The Rangers have a serious talent shortage. If Drury can’t make a deal with a team ahead of him and the players at the top of New York’s wish list are gone, would the GM be willing to trade down?

One potential partner would be the St. Louis Blues, who own the 11th and 15th picks in the first round. Drury would certainly want both of those picks and perhaps something more. Or maybe that No. 5 pick is used in a bigger package to trade back and also land Robert Thomas or Jordan Kyrou, since each Blues forward is rumored to be on the block this offseason.

The Washington Capitals also own two first rounders, Nos. 16 and 18. But those might be too low for the Rangers liking — and it’s doubtful that the Caps would include one of their prized prospects in such a deal.

Swing big

Brad Penner-Imagn Images

There’s another possibility for Drury: Use the No. 5 pick (and maybe his other second-rounder) as the base to explore the trade market for a big-swing move.

Maple Leafs captain Auston Matthews has two years remaining on his contract, which carries a $13.5 million cap hit. However, he sure seemed non-committal about his long-term future in Toronto when this season ended. Perhaps the idea of playing on a line with McKenna convinces Matthews to see a brighter future in Toronto, one with new GM John Chayka and senior executive adviser of hockey operations Mats Sundin trying to revive the Maple Leafs after this season’s collapse.

Or Matthews, who turns 29 before the start of next season, could push for a trade and a new start. The Rangers don’t have a lot to offer Toronto, but starting off with the No. 5 selection in the draft certainly isn’t a bad place to begin talks. Lafreniere, and perhaps New York’s other first-rounder this year, likely would be in play. Maybe Vincent Trocheck is a fit.

The same likely would be true of Brady Tkachuk, though the Ottawa Senators captain says he has no interest in leaving — for New York or anywhere else.

The Rangers desperately need to replenish their prospect pool, and picking fifth could provide a big piece for the future. It’s Drury’s stated desire in this retool to land young NHL players, those that are NHL ready, and draft picks. But he could pivot if a player such as Matthews was a legitimate trade option.

Related Headlines

• Rangers defenseman Will Borgen named to USA roster for World Championship
• Hartford Wolf Pack awards, including Carey Terrance Best 1st-Year Player
• Possible Rangers’ free-agent option off the board, re-signs with Penguins
• Rangers have about $27 million to spend after NHL, players set salary cap