What to make of Will Warren

NEW YORK, NY - APRIL 08: Will Warren #29 of the New York Yankees looks on during the game against the Athletics at Yankee Stadium on April 8, 2026 in New York, New York. (Photo by New York Yankees/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Recency bias can be a heck of a thing, and a concept that may not serve Yankees righty Will Warren all that well. In his most recent outing on Monday against a forgettable Angels lineup, Warren failed to escape the fourth inning, and although they were all unearned, Los Angeles plated four runs under his watch. Although he was not on the hook for any earned runs, it was not a pretty start, but it would be hard to deny the good things in there.

On the whole, that is often the case with Warren. He does not pitch deep into games, and may not always produce the most eye-popping lines, but there is plenty of value in what he brings to the Yankees. Although his role is not set in stone in the future, from the beginning of the 2025 season until now it has been vital to the Yankees. Although that start against the Angels was brief, it was productive in a lot of ways, as he struck out six and walked just one, while technically being off the hook for any of the Halos’ four runs. In fact, a lot of his starts have looked like this, as he’s reached a maximum of 5.2 innings in a start this season, with that being the only time he’s pitched beyond the fifth. It may not be the most satisfying baseball, but it certainly isn’t bad.

View Link

On the season (four starts), Warren has posted a 2.45 ERA and a 3.57 FIP, while striking out more than a batter per inning. The six walks he’s allowed would also suggest an improved rate, though it is obviously very early. Either way, the likely outcome is that the Yankees simply get a Will Warren similar to the one they saw in 2025. There is a valid argument that this would be just fine.

Perhaps Warren’s most valuable asset in 2025 was the fact that has was able to start 33 games for the Yankees, one of just eight big league pitchers to do so. Beyond just simple dependability, which has become an overlooked skill, Warren was a solid major league arm through it all. The now 26-year-old managed a 4.07 FIP in his 162.1 innings of work, and although he completed seven innings in just one of those 33 starts, the Yankees could at least count on trotting him out there every fifth day without needing to worry.

That season was his only real full-time big league work to this point, and at his age, a breakout to some degree would not be the most surprising thing in the world. Given his deep pitching repertoire, highlighted by good off-speed stuff, and a four-seam/sinker combo that can get him by, Warren has a reasonable ceiling, with a floor that is sturdy thanks to his proven durability. Even if huge steps are never really taken, a mid-to-end-rotation arm who can rack up some strikeouts and generally stay out of major trouble can be hugely valuable. For the Yankees, in their current situation, they can see exactly why. With both Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón on the shelf early in 2026, Warren’s presence, whatever it may be, is proving valuable.

Whenever those two All-Star level pitchers return, Warren’s role could change as the 2026 season progresses. But they say you can never have enough pitching, and if Warren can remain healthy and continue to make regular starts for New York, he’ll keep doing his thing as a quietly valuable part of this roster.

Will Warren’s time on the mound may not always be lengthy or particularly flashy, but its value comes from dependability. It’s been only a year-plus of time, but if Warren can maintain his league-average or better production as someone who can consistently trot out every fifth day, the floor is high for a righty that’s proving quite valuable to the Yankees.