
Jon Schneider resigned as Whitefish Bay girls basketball coach after winning the state title to spend more time with his family. He realized the impact of his coaching schedule on his role as a father and husband.
Mentioned in this story
In life, giving up something you love is one of the hardest decisions to make.
Jon Schneider, the now-former Whitefish Bay girls basketball coach, said he made the decision to "give something up that he loves for something he loves even more."
In March, Schneider led Whitefish Bay to the first WIAA state title in program history. After taking some time to enjoy the victory and truly process the decision he was about to make, Schneider resigned in April for a simple reason: to be a more-present husband and father to his wife, Britt, and the couple's 1-year-old daughter, Evie.
"There were many moments, but it was early in the season, in December, where I realized how much I was missing as a father," Schneider said.
"This was my first season [and the 2025 offseason] with a child at home as she was born only a few days after Tosa East knocked us out in sectionals last year. With my teaching and coaching schedule, I would leave for school before she would wake up and, with practice or games, usually not be home until she was already in bed. At the time, she was only 9 months old, so there were many milestones I also knew I was missing out on."
Whitefish Bay girls basketball coach Jon Schneider celebrates with wife Britt and daughter Evie during the Blue Dukes' run to the WIAA Division 2 state title.
Schneider noted that his coaching staff and athletic director Randee Drew knew of his decision to step down at the end of the season, but team members were not informed as Schneider wanted them to focus on the goal of winning a state title.
"Once I had made the decision in December, I told my coaching staff and AD, but did not share with the girls or anyone else because I never wanted to take any focus off of what we knew could be a special year," Schneider said. "Of course, even though we knew we had a chance to win state, I never knew it would be a storybook ending like it has. I feel so incredibly blessed to have had a season like this to cap off an 11-year run here at Bay."
Jon Schneider resigned to be a more-present husband and father, realizing he was missing important moments with his young daughter.
He led Whitefish Bay to its first WIAA state title in program history.
His coaching schedule often kept him away from home during key moments, as he would leave before his daughter woke up and return after she was in bed.
He resigned in April, shortly after the state title victory in March.


Bayern Munich has started discussions with Newcastle about signing Anthony Gordon this summer.
Excitement Builds as Stars Converge for 2026 PGA Championship at Aronimink!
Jared Jones impresses in rehab assignment for Indianapolis
Valverde clarifies Tchouameni fight: 'At no time did my teammate hit me'
Red Sox's Roman Anthony may join injured list, adding to team's woes.
See every story in Sports — including breaking news and analysis.
The Blue Dukes captured a share of the program's first North Shore Conference title in two decades. The regular season included marquee wins over 2025 Division 1 state semifinalist Pewaukee on the road, along with conference rival and co-NSC champion Hartford. The crown jewel of the campaign was the 64-63 nail-biting victory in the WIAA Division 2 state title game over Beaver Dam that gave Schneider the storybook ending that felt possible, but not expected.
Exactly a month after the title game, on April 14, Schneider called for a program-wide meeting to say he would be stepping down. Tears flowed after the announcement, but Schneider said every player understood his decision, even through feelings of shock and sadness.
"As hard as it was for everyone, and even through all the tears, the girls were so supportive and understanding, and they all also expressed their gratitude for our time together," Schneider said. "I told them that they were the ones to thank for allowing myself and staff to be a part of their basketball careers."
Schneider said Drew even tried to convince him to stay for one more season.
"I told him, 'Talk to me again after you win state,'" Drew said with a laugh.
"My thought process in trying to convince Jon to come back was that he could see it out with the rest of the girls that he's taught and watched grow throughout their time in the community. But, with him becoming a father and the new kid on the block as a dad, I totally respect him for making a completely mature decision and understand why he made his decision."
Whitefish Bay coach Jon Schneider talks with Carrington Balthasar during the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game.
Whitefish Bay posted a message from Schneider to his team on April 24 in the Blue Duke Bulletin, a community newsletter. Here's an excerpt from that message from Schneider:
"All I ask is you know this is a decision I made to be a better father to the most amazing little girl that I have ever known. Some day you may feel and understand that same feeling. A feeling each one of your parents knows well. Being a girls coach for so many years, I have been around enough to know what high character looks like and coaching wonderful young ladies like yourself, I hope she can grow up one day to be as amazing as you all. Becoming a girl dad seems now so incredibly fitting. You are a championship team not just because of your talent, but because of who you are as individuals. Thank you for being who you are."
It's been a special year for the Blue Dukes community with five state championships in this school year: boys soccer, boys and girls swimming, and boys and girls basketball.
"Selfishly, I'd like to have a decision made on June 14, which is our last day of school and the kids graduate, but I want to make the right hire," Drew said about finding Schneider's replacement, noting the summer window for the girls to get some work in before the 2026-27 season.
"I don't want to make a splash hire and repeat the cycle on a high-level job every two to three years. I want to find the right person to lead this program because there's big shoes to fill. Jon was an excellent coach and a better person."
Although he's no longer involved with the program, Schneider still plans to attend some games in the future as a fan. He's still involved with the Junior Duke Academy, the Whitefish Bay youth basketball program, and will continue to run spring camps for 2nd-8th graders through the spring into the summer.
"Coaching will always be on the radar," Schneider said. "Sports is in my blood, and basketball has been such an important part of my life, so this is likely not retirement, but more of a break.
"I think the only question would be what level and what role. Whether it is youth, high school, college, boys, girls, whatever, I am sure coaching my daughter's team down the road will be of interest, but either way, I know for the short future I am going to soak up the time with my little one as much as I can."
Whitefish Bay High School's Rowan Counsell (23) jumps over Beaver Dam High School's Emma Julka (23) during the first half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Whitefish Bay High School's Rowan Counsell (23) and Beaver Dam High School's Emma Julka (23) dive for position during the first half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Whitefish Bay High School celebrates its victory over Beaver Dam High School in the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Whitefish Bay High School celebrates its victory over Beaver Dam High School in the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Whitefish Bay High School lifts the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship trophy after their victory over Beaver Dam High School on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Whitefish Bay High School lifts the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship trophy after their victory over Beaver Dam High School on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Beaver Dam High School's Nataya Donaldson (31) attempts to scores and fouls Whitefish Bay High School's Sage Miskel (22) during the second half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Whitefish Bay High School's Carrington Balthasar (24) shoots the ball as Beaver Dam High School's Sheamarie Ashley (0) guards during the second half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Beaver Dam High School's Sheamarie Ashley (0) guards Whitefish Bay High School's Madeline Volpe (2) during the second half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
Beaver Dam High School's Joelee Drzonek (33) attempts to steal the ball from Whitefish Bay High School's Leyla Burkemper (5) during the first half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
1 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School's Rowan Counsell (23) jumps over Beaver Dam High School's Emma Julka (23) during the first half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
1 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School's Rowan Counsell (23) jumps over Beaver Dam High School's Emma Julka (23) during the first half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
2 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School's Rowan Counsell (23) and Beaver Dam High School's Emma Julka (23) dive for position during the first half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
3 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School celebrates its victory over Beaver Dam High School in the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
4 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School celebrates its victory over Beaver Dam High School in the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
5 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School lifts the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship trophy after their victory over Beaver Dam High School on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
6 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School lifts the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship trophy after their victory over Beaver Dam High School on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
7 / 10
Beaver Dam High School's Nataya Donaldson (31) attempts to scores and fouls Whitefish Bay High School's Sage Miskel (22) during the second half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
8 / 10
Whitefish Bay High School's Carrington Balthasar (24) shoots the ball as Beaver Dam High School's Sheamarie Ashley (0) guards during the second half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
9 / 10
Beaver Dam High School's Sheamarie Ashley (0) guards Whitefish Bay High School's Madeline Volpe (2) during the second half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
10 / 10
Beaver Dam High School's Joelee Drzonek (33) attempts to steal the ball from Whitefish Bay High School's Leyla Burkemper (5) during the first half of the WIAA Division 2 girls basketball championship game on Saturday March 14, 2026 at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon, Wisconsin.
This article originally appeared on Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: Whitefish Bay coach talks about why he resigned after state title win