Who would win Russell Wilson-Geno Smith New York Jets QB battle?

MORE: Joe Burrow praises Cincinnati Bengals offseason moves, sets expectations

Wilson can likely play another year or two at a competitive level. If the Jets want to end their nearly two-decade playoff drought, he could give them a legitimate shot.

Why Geno Smith could win the job

Smith brings one of the most valuable traits in sports: competitive patience. He not only waited behind Wilson in Seattle but has shown resilience throughout his career. That patience ultimately created the opportunity for his resurgence.

Smith endured difficult stretches with both New York teams from 2013 to 2017, learning how to navigate adversity. When he joined Seattle in 2019, he recognized a potential opportunity and stayed ready. That decision paid off.

After the Seahawks traded Wilson in 2022, they turned to Smith instead of drafting a replacement. He led the team to the playoffs that season and posted winning records as a starter over the next two years. In 2025, the Raiders traded for Smith, partly due to his strong relationship with Pete Carroll.

MORE: NFL on track to avoid officiating disaster for 2026 season

Although his time with the Raiders didn’t fully pan out, Smith still demonstrated he can perform at this stage of his career. Now, he has another chance to prove himself—assuming Wilson joins the roster.

Likely winner?

Smith enters this situation well-positioned, especially with his familiarity in New York. Still, Wilson’s leadership and résumé could allow him to win over teammates and coaches quickly.

That said, Wilson likely won’t have a long leash. We’ve seen similar situations before, and if he struggles, the team could turn to Smith. In the long run, Smith’s patience and steady approach might help him reclaim the starting role—possibly as soon as 2026.

So the question remains: who should start for the Jets—Russell Wilson or Geno Smith?