Will Warren Has Caused the Best Problem Possible for the Yankees

While the 26-year-old certainly showed flashes of brilliance across his 33 starts in 2025, there is no question that this is the best run of Warren's career to date, and considering how well he pitched in Spring Training, we probably should have seen this coming.

Now, New York must question what it will do with the rest of its young arms it has emerging in its system.

New York Yankees pitcher Will Warren. Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images.

We just saw Elmer Rodriguez earlier in the week, and Carlos Lagrange and Ben Hess are probably not far away, either (although Lagrange's command remains an issue). That's not to mention all of the other pitchers the Yanks have in the minor leagues.

Rodriguez, Lagrange and Hess in particular have had the spotlight on them for quite some time now, but with Warren developing into a potential star and Warren also looking quite impressive, you have to wonder if there is room for any of them in the near future.

Once Rodon and Cole return, the Yankees' starting rotation will feature Cole, Fried, Rodon, Schlittler and Warren. Weathers will probably head to the bullpen, and Gil was recently demoted to Triple-A after a rough start to the year.

Rodriguez seems bound to head back to Triple-A the second Rodon is activated, and Lagrange and Hess appear destined to stay down in the minors.

But could this force a trade for New York?

It's always wise to trade from an area of strength, and the Yankees have pitchers coming out of their ears. It is highly, highly doubtful that all of these young hurlers will remain in New York long term.

If the Yanks need something before the trade deadline (and they almost certainly will), I can absolutely envision a scenario in which Brian Cashman bites the bullet and decides to start parting with some of his talented young pitchers.

The Yankees had a pitching surplus before 2026. Now that Warren is taking a major step to the next level, the surplus has expanded even further.

What a great problem to have.

Yankees Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Yankees. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.