Would Murillo be a good option for Barcelona instead of Alessandro Bastoni?

Murillo not playing at an established elite Champions League club yet makes the transfer feel attainable for Barcelona. Compare this to someone like Gabriel Saliba and Willian Pacho, dream signings yes, but wholly unattainable given their contract situation, Arsenal and PSG’s progress in the Champions League this season, their overall transfer value and the club’s stature in relation to their necessity to win vs to sell players. Murillo’s transfer would be a savvy pickup uncannily similar to Raphinha’s from Leeds. Nottingham Forest will have plenty of offers this summer given their exploits in the Europa League for the likes of Elliot Anderson and their young core. Don’t be surprised if they decide to cash in on Murillo.

Murillo is extremely calm in possession, a naturally progressive passer and comfortable breaking pressure from deep areas. He plays with unusual freedom for a centre-back, almost like a Brazilian full-back stepping into midfield, a bit like Marcelo. He is left-footed and has the perfect athletic profile for Hansi Flick’s system. With superb recovery speed, explosiveness, aggression, and transition defending all suit Flick’s high-line system. He looks naturally comfortable defending huge spaces and recovering during counter attacks. He steps into duels confidently and attacks situations instead of retreating passively. Moreover, he would be an excellent partner for Pau Cubarsi. The youngster provides composure and intelligence while Murillo adds athleticism, aggression, and ball-carrying power.

Bastoni is the leading candidate Barcelona has identified for the position next season but there are doubts over whether he wants to move and his lofty price tag. The Italy international is elite at everything Barcelona need but has looked best in a three-man backline system. However, it’s clear that when the high line is exposed repeatedly in Europe and Bastoni is the last line of defence, he may not look so elite without another defender behind him other than just Cubarsi. Barcelona need someone with elite recovery speed to be able to succeed in defending a counter attack with Europe’s elite strikers like Julian Alvarez and Ousmane Dembele. Even at times in transition against a sole winger, Bastoni will not be fast enough. That’s just not him. Wasting precious transfer funds on a tactical misfit is not something Barcelona can afford at this time. Hansi Flick has said this already: “We have to make the right decision about the transfer period, don’t make stupid decisions, we must be perfect.”

Murillo is not the tallest centre-back profile, and while he is aggressive aerially, he may never become one of those physically overwhelming defenders that dominate every cross or long ball situation. Against highly direct teams, that lack of elite height could occasionally become a vulnerability. However, Barcelona have historically prioritized mobility, recovery speed, technical quality and defensive intelligence over simply having towering centre-backs, which makes the concern feel manageable within Hansi Flick’s system. At the end of the day, players like Murillo are exactly the kind of risks Barcelona used to identify before the rest of the market exploded around them. He may not be the finished article yet, and there are still questions about how he would adapt to an aggressive offside-trap system over an entire season, but the raw tools are undeniable. The athleticism, recovery speed, aggression, freedom on the ball and Brazilian instinctiveness all feel tailor-made for modern football. Next to Pau Cubarsí, it genuinely feels like Barcelona could build something special for the next decade if they move before everyone else realizes what Murillo is becoming. *What do you think about Murillo? Feel free to share your thoughts, predictions, opinions and answers in the comments section below!*