Yankees April Approval Poll: Brian Cashman

The dominant narrative of the early going has been the Yankees’ stellar starting pitching. Cam Schlittler and Max Fried are one and two in fWAR among all qualified pitchers. The highest ERA of their four regular starters belongs to Ryan Weathers at 3.21, and he has acquitted himself well since joining from Miami over the winter. Both he and Will Warren have a double-digit strikeout start to their names, the latter looking like he has taken the next step in his development after a solid rookie campaign. Even with the since-demoted Luis Gil’s struggles, the rotation is far and away the best in baseball, with the most innings per start (5.8), lowest ERA (2.70) and FIP (3.21), and most fWAR (4.6) of any starting staff in the land.

Fried and Schlittler aren’t the only ones on the team performing among the best in their discipline. Aaron Judge and Ben Rice place third and seventh, respectively, in position player fWAR, meaning the Yankees have the two best pitchers and two of the seven best hitters in all of baseball, which is certainly a good starting point for any roster. Judge and Rice became the first pair of Yankees teammates in franchise history with at least 10 home runs and at least 20 walks before the end of April, the pair placing second and third in wRC+ among qualified hitters in the league.

It’s a good thing that pair is more than pulling their weight when you consider the output of the rest of the offense. The Yankees do not have another lineup regular with a wRC+ above Cody Bellinger’s 108 mark. Amed Rosario has been a remarkable catalyst when he bats against lefties, but his defensive limitations prevent him from being an everyday starter. As we alluded to earlier, the bottom of the order was a black hole through the first three weeks, Jazz Chisholm Jr., Austin Wells, Ryan McMahon, and José Caballero combining to give the Yankees an automatic out in almost half their lineup. Fortunately that has turned around some in the final half of April. Every member of that quartet has posted a wRC+ of at least 119 since the start of the Royals series, and it is no surprise that this coincided with the Yankees’ best stretch of results.

That leaves the bullpen as the unit that struggled the most for the entire month. The group sits middle of the pack league-wide in ERA (3.86), FIP (3.97), and fWAR (0.7), though it’s easy to envision a scenario where those metrics are worse had the starting rotation not accounted for so many innings pitched. They optioned (and recalled) Jake Bird to the minors for the second time in his short Yankees tenure, you can reliably pencil Camilo Doval in to give up a home run in every outing, Fernando Cruz is walking almost a batter per inning, there’s a fear of pitching the suddenly-important Brent Headrick into the ground with 17 appearances in 31 games, and even David Bednar is a human vasopressor when he closes games.

Just when it looked like the Yankees would go injury-free in April, the bug started to bite in the final week. Giancarlo Stanton landed on the IL with a calf strain and his replacement, Jasson Domínguez, had to exit the series finale against the Rangers; he is undergoing imaging after getting hit on the elbow by a fastball. Conversely, they do have reinforcements on the horizon. Carlos Rodón is about a week and change away (two rehab starts) from rejoining the team after undergoing offseason surgery to remove bone chips in his elbow. Gerrit Cole is probably a month behind his rotation mate as he completes a lengthy rehab from Tommy John surgery. Anthony Volpe could join up with the big-league squad during the upcoming homestand after his offseason surgery to repair a partially torn labrum in his left shoulder. The players they will eventually displace from the active roster is a question they will have to answer shortly, but it’s a good problem to have when you’ve got veterans reinforcing a team that’s already performing well.

That brings us to today’s task. Do you approve of the job Brian Cashman has done through the end of April? On one hand, the Yankees sit atop the division with the best record in the AL posting the second-most runs per game and the lowest staff ERA in the AL. On the other hand, the areas that everyone identified as weak spots over the offseason — third base and the bullpen — continue to drag the team down. The polarizing GM certainly elicits stronger feelings than can be captured in a one-word response — you may feel a question such as the one being posed requires more nuance, greater elaboration, or a wider selection of options than just a “yes” or a “no,” however for the sake of this exercise, a binary question works best.

Note: This is the same poll that is currently appearing on the Feed, so if you’ve voted there, that should already be counted.