Yankees waste Schlittler’s gem, fall to Brewers in extras

Q: What were Cam Schlittler's stats in the game against the Brewers?

Cam Schlittler pitched six innings, allowing no runs and only two hits.

Q: How did the Yankees lose to the Brewers in extra innings?

The Yankees lost 4-3 after leading in both the eighth and tenth innings, with their bullpen unable to close out the game.

Q: Who scored the tying run for the Brewers against the Yankees?

Brice Turang scored the tying run for the Brewers in the eighth inning, sliding home safely past the tag of Austin Wells.

Q: What was the Yankees' run total in their game against the Brewers?

The Yankees managed to score three runs in the game despite having seven hits and seven walks.

MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN - MAY 09: Brice Turang #2 of the Milwaukee Brewers slides safely into home plate past the tag of Austin Wells #28 of the New York Yankees to tie the game in the eighth inning against the New York Yankees at American Family Field on May 09, 2026 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. (Photo by John Fisher/Getty Images) | Getty Images On Friday night in Milwaukee, the Yankees were shut down by Brewers’ phenom pitcher Jacob Misiorowski to spectacular effect. On Saturday, it was the Yankees’ turn to throw their young star, and he was quite good himself. Cam Schlittler ended up going six innings, for the Yankees, allowing no runs on just two hits. He even came back from taking a line drive off the leg to put in another excellent outing. It’s just that the rest of the team didn’t pull their collective weight. The Yankees managed just three runs on Saturday, despite seven hits and seven walks. However, they twice held late leads, as they were ahead in both the eighth and tenth innings. The bullpen couldn’t close things out either though, as they dropped a frustrating one to the Brewers, 4-3 in 10 innings. Before the frustration, the game started on a pretty decent note. It took just one batter for the Yankees to surpass their run total from Friday night. On the second pitch of the game, took deep to give the Yankees a good start. In the bottom of the first, there was a scary moment as Cam Schlittler took a comeback liner off the calf, causing him to limp around for a bit. After the trainer came out to look at him and some practice pitches, he remained in and struck out . The Yankees picked up a second run in the fourth inning, although it was a missed chance at even more. and opened the inning with hits, giving the Yankees runners at the corner, with a walk then loading the bases. However, Harrison got the next two outs, leaving the inning up to Goldschmidt. The first baseman picked up another RBI after couldn’t handle his liner at third, giving Goldschmidt an RBI single. The Yankees couldn’t tack on any more in the inning, though. After Schlittler left the game, it didn’t take long for Milwaukee to get on the board. On the very first pitch reliever threw in the seventh inning, Bauers crushed a homer into the second deck in right field, cutting into the Yankees’ lead. Headrick came back after that to get through the seventh and the first out of the eighth. replaced Headrick and got the second out of the seventh before Brice Turang kept the inning alive with a single. Turang then stole second and you knew what was coming after that. dropped a single into left field and Turang just beat ’s throw home, tying the game up. With little room for error, came out and threw a nice 1-2-3 inning on just 12 pitches, sending the game to extras. It seemed like the Yankees would then go down pretty quickly in order in the 10th. and Bellinger couldn’t do anything with the auto-runner at second, with getting intentionally walked, as is custom. However, McMahon, having come in earlier for Rosario as a defensive replacement, poked a single up the middle to give the Yankees the lead back. Judge would get caught in a rundown after the run scored and the throw home was cut off to end the inning though, and the Yankees would regret missing out on the chance to get insurance runs. For the bottom of the 10th, the Yankees turned to . He got off to a rocky start, as a wild pitch moved the runner up, and he then issued a walk. While a fly out ended up keeping the runner in place in the next at-bat, a grounder left Caballero with no play, tying the game back up. The Yankees then went to , who immediately got a ground ball. However for whatever reason, Hill tried to go to third to get the lead runner. His throw hit Rengifo, the runner, allowing everyone to be safe. Hill then finally did get the second out, but it was a Contreras fly out to right that was deep enough for Aaron Judge’s throw home to be a couple steps late. You can somewhat chalk up Friday’s loss as just running into a freak of nature. Harrison and the pitchers Milwaukee used on Saturday are all pretty good, but the Yankees wasted this one. Tomorrow, the Yankees and Brewers will wrap up their series with one final game in Milwaukee. It’s also a notable one for the Yankees especially, as will make his return from the injured list, opposite for the Brewers. First pitch in that one will be at 2:10 pm ET.