Aranda Hit The Clutch, Simpson Hit The Gas: Rays 5, Yankees 4

Apr 11, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; Tampa Bay Rays first baseman Jonathan Aranda (8) is doused with water after hitting a walk off single against the New York Yankeesin the tenth inning at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images | Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

This game started like a chess match and ended like a street race, and once the Rays hit the gas, the Yankees could not catch a break.

For six innings, this one had all the tension of a real pitchers’ duel. Nick Martinez was not overpowering, but he was calm throughout, which against the Yankees counts for plenty. He opened the night by walking Trent Grisham, giving up a single to Cody Bellinger, then watching Bellinger steal second with Ben Rice and Giancarlo Stanton lurking. That looked like early trouble. Instead, Martinez struck out Rice, then got Stanton to line out. Crisis avoided.

Max Fried was doing the same thing on the other side, keeping the Rays from getting comfortable and making every baserunner feel important, especially after retiring the Rays in order in the first.

The Yankees struck first in the second when Austin Wells hit a solo homer to right, but the Rays answered right away. Junior Caminero doubled, Ben Williamson moved him over with a groundout, and Jonny DeLuca dropped a single into right to tie it at 1-1. That became the shape of the night. New York makes a move; Tampa Bay counters to keep victory within reach.

Austin Wells (1)

Opponent: Tampa Bay Rays
Pitcher: Nick Martinez
Date: 04/11/2026 pic.twitter.com/68MDUceWhZ

— Yankees Home Runs (@NYY_HR) April 11, 2026

On board! pic.twitter.com/xpmUYIZfLo

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 11, 2026

Martinez was solid through four innings in a game that felt like it might come down to whichever side blinked first. The Yankees nearly forced the issue in the fifth when Grisham walked, Bellinger singled, and Rice walked to load the bases with two outs. That ended Martinez’s night and brought Kevin Kelly in to face Stanton, which is not exactly a relaxing sentence to type, much less a situation for a reliever to face. Kelly struck him out swinging and kept the game tied. Crisis avoided again.

The Rays finally moved in front in the sixth, and Jonathan Aranda was at the center of it. Taylor Walls singled and advanced to third with some great baserunning on a Vilade single. Then Aranda lifted a sacrifice fly just shy of the warning track in left to score Walls and make it 2-1. It was exactly the kind of at-bat that matters in games like this, not trying to do too much, just a productive at-bat.

Tag! We're ⬆️ pic.twitter.com/JjnilZ0RUb

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 11, 2026

Of course, one-run leads against the Yankees never feel all that secure. In the eighth with Bryan Baker on the mound, Stanton walked, and Jazz Chisholm Jr. doubled. The next at-bat went about as well as it could with Wells hitting a flyout to shallow left field, preventing the pinch-runner Randal Grichuk from scoring from third. Then former Ray José Caballero ripped a two-run double to left to put the Yankees back on top 3-2. Caballero advanced to third on a balk from Baker, who had no situational awareness to realize he was attempting to pick off a runner at first that was already at second. A Rosario flyout would stop the bleeding, but after all the careful work of the first seven innings, the Yankees had flipped the game late.

José Caballero drives in two and gives the Yankees the lead! pic.twitter.com/yrp4muSEEj

— MLB (@MLB) April 12, 2026

The Rays countered again.

Nick Fortes doubled to start the bottom of the eighth, and Chandler Simpson came in to run. That was when the game started putting on running shoes. Simpson changes innings just by existing on the bases. Seriously, the man is a cheat code. Walls bunted him to third, then Yandy Díaz chopped one with the Yankees’ infield all the way in. The hop forced Ben Rice off his feet, giving Simpson enough time to score and pulling Rice far enough off the bag for Díaz to beat it out, tying the game 3-3.

YES YANDY pic.twitter.com/apQG55jygx

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

The ninth inning started with Judge getting walked and stealing second. With two outs, the Rays intentionally walked Rice, bringing Grichuk to the plate, who flew out to close the inning. A DeLuca single was the only offense the Rays could put together in the bottom of the ninth, taking us to extras.

The tenth saw another round of moves and countermoves in this game.

The Yankees scratched across a run in the top half on Caballero’s RBI single off Cole Sulser, so the Rays came up in the bottom of the inning down 4-3.

Cedric Mullins started at second as the automatic runner. Simpson led off and dropped a soft bunt single. He has now reached base safely in all 14 games the Rays have played this year. Then he stole second because he’s what the kids call “Him.” At that point, the Yankees were no longer defending an inning. They were trying to slow down a speed demon.

Walls followed with another soft bunt single, scoring Mullins to tie the game. That made it 4-4, put Simpson on third, and cranked the pressure all the way up.

🚨🚨🚨 pic.twitter.com/sny39Dfxwm

— Tampa Bay Rays (@RaysBaseball) April 12, 2026

And the Yankees knew it and felt it too.

They intentionally walked Yandy Díaz to load the bases and set up the force at any base. Hunter Feduccia struck out, giving New York a brief glimmer of hope. Then they brought Cody Bellinger into the infield as an extra defender, fully committing to stop the exact kind of play the Rays wanted. Everybody in the building knew the plan. The Rays were going to put the ball on the ground, make the Yankees move fast, and trust their legs.

It still was not enough.

Aranda chopped a ball to second that got past one Yankees defender, and Chisholm couldn’t come up with it cleanly. Had he fielded it cleanly, the Yankees might have had a slim shot at turning two.

Jazz could've tagged Diaz and thrown to first for the double play. Instead he bobbles the ball and the Rays walk it off pic.twitter.com/1ij5OyebPQ

— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) April 12, 2026

Instead, Simpson raced home, and the Rays walked off with a 5-4 win after scoring two runs in the tenth in an inning where nothing left the infield and nothing needed to. That is the sort of ending Rays fans can appreciate on a spiritual level. The Yankees pulled Bellinger in, packed the infield, and still could not keep up once Tampa Bay turned the end of an MLB game into a 9U travel ball game. Just keep running.

Aranda was the clutch bat all night. His sac fly gave the Rays the lead in the sixth, and his grounder won the game in the tenth.

Simpson was the gas in the chaos engine. His speed helped spark the tying run in the eighth, then blew open the tenth. He turned soft contact into pressure, pressure into panic, and panic into two runs. Once he got loose, the Yankees looked like they were trying to catch smoke in a glove.

The win is the Rays’ first series win at Tropicana Field since September 20-22, 2024, against the Toronto Blue Jays.

The Rays and Yankees are back at it tomorrow as the Rays look to sweep the series. First pitch is at 1:40 pm.