Tiny ball for the win: Rays 4 Blue Jays 3
Rays win 4-3 against Blue Jays with a small ball strategy!
Bomani Jones compares Matthew Stafford's career to Carson Palmer's, suggesting Stafford may not be a Hall of Famer. Despite Stafford's MVP and better stats, Jones believes their careers are closely aligned.
Mentioned in this story
On the heels of his first-ever MVP, many are clamoring for Matthew Stafford to be a first-ballot Hall of Famer when he eventually retires. NFL pundit Bomani Jones is not one of the people who think that way, though.
The podcast host recently said the Stafford's career compares more closely to Carson Palmer than any other quarterback, and no one is claiming Palmer should be in the Hall of Fame.
"The comp is Carson Palmer. It has always been the comp, right?," Jones said on "The Dominique Foxworth Show." "I've seen people get offended by that. But I think three-time Pro Bowler Carson Palmer and three-time Pro Bowler Matthew Stafford have a decent bit in common. If somehow Carson got himself a Super Bowl, we would have to talk about him the same way."
The differences between Palmer and Stafford are more than just the Super Bowl, though. Stafford has the MVP award as well as one first-team All-Pro nod. Statistically, Stafford has Palmer beat in career completion percentage, passing yards per game and passing touchdowns per game (albeit barely).
But Palmer, like Stafford until he joined the Rams, didn't play on a lot of playoff teams. He made the postseason just three times in 14 years and made the Super Bowl once (where he lost with the Arizona Cardinals to the Pittsburgh Steelers). Stafford made the playoffs just three times before he was traded to the Rams, but has now been to the postseason four times in five seasons and played in 10 playoff games (compared to his three with the Detroit Lions).
To say Stafford is the same as Palmer is a bit disingenuous considering how Stafford's career has looked in the past five years. Yes, he was with the Rams during that time, but Palmer also turned his career around a bit when he joined the Cardinals in his 10th season and never looked as good as Stafford did in L.A.
Bomani Jones believes that both quarterbacks share similar career achievements, including being three-time Pro Bowl selections, which leads him to draw this comparison.
While Stafford has an MVP award and a first-team All-Pro nod, Palmer's career lacks a Super Bowl, which Jones highlights as a significant difference.
Despite discussions around his potential Hall of Fame status following his MVP win, Bomani Jones argues that Stafford's career may not warrant first-ballot induction.
Rays win 4-3 against Blue Jays with a small ball strategy!
Stefon Diggs found not guilty of assault; lawyer speaks out on athlete targeting
L'Jarius Sneed's assault charges dismissed; he's now a free agent.
Check out the Purple Row community's predictions for the 2026 MLB season!
Rangers let Yankees off the hook, losing 7-4 in opener
Pistons hold off Cavaliers 111-101 in playoff opener
See every story in Sports — including breaking news and analysis.
This point will be moot, too, if Stafford wins another ring with the Rams.
This article originally appeared on Rams Wire: Bomani Jones thinks Matthew Stafford resembles Carson Palmer