Exclusive: New signing tipped to become next Manchester City captain

These exits, combined with Rodri’s recent injury struggles, have forced fans and former players alike to look toward newer faces in the dressing room – specifically January arrival Marc Guéhi – as potential candidates to inherit the armband for the 2026/27 season.

Who could be the next Man City captain?

Speaking exclusively to City Xtra on behalf of 10bet, former Manchester City and Scotland centre-back Colin Hendry was quizzed on the debate around who should succeed Bernardo Silva as the club’s captain from the 2026/27 season onwards.

“Initially, I’d say Rodri would be the one for me. He’s been a little injury-ravaged recently, so it depends on consistency,” Hendry pointed out. He continued, “Marc Guéhi at the back, possibly, but there are two or three candidates.

“I’m happy if it’s a midfielder or a defender. I’m not so keen on goalkeepers being captains – that’s just my personal preference – I prefer an outfield player.

“Bernardo has been a great servant to Manchester City, but there are several candidates more than sufficient to take on the role.”

Why Guehi and Rodri should be considered for Man City’s captaincy

Since his £20 million move from Crystal Palace in January 2026, Marc Guéhi has quickly established himself as a pillar of Pep Guardiola’s defence, with senior figures like Ruben Dias and Josko Gvardiol sidelined through injury.

Guéhi’s rapid integration into the Manchester City style of play has surpassed expectations of many supporters, making Colin Hendry’s recent suggestion of a captaincy bid far from speculative.

While Rodri remains the natural heir to many, his fitness issues and some doubts over his long-term future amid interest from Real Madrid have cast doubt over his abilities to steer the club forward from a captaincy role.

If Pep Guardiola follows his tradition of allowing the squad to vote on their leadership group, Marc Guéhi’s composure and vocal presence at the back could see him follow in the footsteps of previous iconic defensive captains.