Forget the 40: The true measure of Carnell Tate

Baudo and Tate sat next to each other at practice and hung out after school, playing video games.

Marist is touted as Chicago's No. 1 Catholic college preparatory institution, and its football team plays in the toughest conference in the state. The program packs the stands and wins a lot.

For as long as any Marist coaches can remember, no freshman had played varsity. Tate made them reconsider. He was 6-foot-1 with silky-smooth moves that former Marist head coach Ron Dawczak said were "ridiculous." Tate ran precise routes, and seemed to be the perfect antidote for a team that was hovering around .500 near the midseason mark in 2019 and lacking a No. 1 receiver.

One day, Dawczak asked him if he wanted to play on varsity and told him to ask his parents if he could.

"I just remember he had a big smile on his face," Dawczak said.

Tate made the transition look easy. Over the next nine games, he made a spectacular over-the-shoulder catch while falling down, and plucked a Hail Mary pass from four defenders for a touchdown. "We were all looking at each other going, 'Holy cow,'" Dawczak said.

He caught 28 passes for 444 yards and five touchdowns, and led Marist to the state semifinals.

After the season, a college scout came to Marist to recruit an upperclassman, and Dawczak suggested he watch a little film on Tate.

"As soon as I mentioned that he was a freshman," Dawczak said, "he rolled his eyes and kind of chuckled. He was going to humor me, and I put the film on of Carnell, and after like three plays, he goes, 'You know what, Coach? I never do this, but I'm going to offer this kid a scholarship today.'"

Then, the COVID-19 pandemic hit.

Baudo and Tate FaceTimed every day and played Fortnite and would "just talk crap to each other," Baudo said.

He got to know Tate on a different level during those isolating days.

"If he cares about you, he really cares about you and would do anything for you," Baudo said. "If he loves you, he treats you like family."

Dontrell Jackson, Marist's receivers coach at the time, remembers driving his son to west Chicago during the pandemic to throw footballs in the fresh air with Tate.

Jackson picked up Tate at the home he shared with his mom and spotted a turf field nearby. Tate told him to keep driving.

"Coach, we can't go right there," Tate told him. "People just drive by and shoot at us for no reason."

Jackson drove to a safer place. It made him think about the mindset of the 15-year-old, and how growing up in one of the most dangerous parts of the city affected the way he carried himself.

"[He was a] mini professional," Jackson said, operating with a sense of precision regarding his routes and schoolwork.

"He's a young man, but an old soul," he said.

TATE RECEIVED AN offer to play at IMG Academy in Florida, but he was hesitant to go. His parents wouldn't get to see him play as much, and he'd miss his friends at Marist.

But Illinois' 2021 spring football season was in doubt because of the pandemic, so Tate moved to Florida. His dad said it was more than that.

"He enjoyed his time at home," LeSean Tate said, "but [IMG] was pretty much college. It was like you just went to college early. You're away from your family, you're working out. ...

"It's just a business. Like, 'This is what I've got to do to get my body ready for the next level.' So, he's always been more mature. He understands it's for a purpose."

Tate's mom was less enthusiastic. She had no idea that Tate's instant success would take her son away from her so quickly. But she didn't stand in his way.

She called or FaceTimed him every day, multiple times if necessary. She flew down to watch him play when she could.

Tate thrived in Florida, and he had offers from LSU, Michigan and Notre Dame.

He chose Ohio State because of its tradition of sending receivers to the NFL. Five Buckeyes receivers have been picked in the first round in the past four drafts -- Chris Olave and Garrett Wilson in 2022, Jaxon Smith-Njigba in 2023, Marvin Harrison Jr. in 2024 and Emeka Egbuka in 2025.

Tate wrapped up his studies at IMG a semester early and arrived in Columbus, Ohio, in January 2023. He roomed with freshman Brandon Inniss, a top-10 receiver in the 2023 recruiting class and a reminder of how hard it would be to get on the field. Ashley, always her son's biggest supporter, implored her neighbors to buy his jersey.

By April, Buckeyes coach Ryan Day was raving to reporters about Tate's maturity, and how he handled the transition, from academics to training, with such ease.

In the spring game, Tate caught a 37-yard touchdown pass from Kyle McCord and nonchalantly accepted his teammates' congratulations.

AS USUAL, ASHLEY GRIGGS FaceTimed her son on July 15, 2023. She was going to a class reunion. Tate planned to hang out with some teammates that night.

Hours later, Griggs was shot on West Washington Boulevard, a spot she had hung out at as a child and just a block or two from where Tate grew up. She was taken to Mount Sinai Hospital, where she was pronounced dead. She was 40 years old.

Tate received a middle-of-the-night call from his uncle, who told Tate his mother had been killed in a drive-by shooting.

Baudo, who had arrived in Columbus a month earlier as a preferred walk-on, woke up the next morning to eight missed calls from LeSean Tate and Brian Hartline, the Buckeyes' offensive coordinator.

Baudo immediately tried to get a hold of Tate. His calls went unanswered. Baudo didn't have a car, so he ran three miles to Tate's apartment and "basically broke in." Inniss was asleep, he said, and Tate's door was closed, so he sat there for 25 minutes, trying to figure out what to do.

He woke up Inniss, and they sat on the couch and debated how to approach Tate. Eventually, they knocked on the door, walked in and found Tate sitting in bed. He told them to give him a couple of minutes.

When he came out, Baudo said, they hugged him and told him they loved him. They sat on the balcony together, and talked a little bit, as much as he wanted. Tate's dad flew to Columbus to pick him up.

Though Tate hadn't even taken an official snap at Ohio State, his mom's death shook the program. Hartline said he had "great, candid" conversations with Griggs.

"She was very outgoing," Hartline said. "She loved to hang out with people and was very passionate about her son.

"She'd light up the room."

Hartline said he had never dealt with a death so close to a player before Griggs died, and he sometimes questioned if he was handling it properly. Hartline said he talked to Tate and asked if he was OK, but it was challenging because of Tate's introverted nature.

Hartline said there is a fine line between checking in and nagging, and he tried not to cross it.

"The whole time I was like, 'Man, are you good?'" said Hartline, now the head coach at South Florida. "He wasn't, you know, he just never let it affect him and what he does and the people around him. And he just had a very pro approach to it. But the receiver room was heavy around him. I was as heavy as I could be around him, but I just. ... That still to this day has not really left me, to be honest.

"It's weird to talk about. ... He's the one who went through it, not me. It's just, to have someone I care about so much lose someone so close to him, I don't know. I can't say I knew how to handle it."

According to a document obtained from the Cook County state's attorney's office, Griggs was shot multiple times in the head. Four others were injured in the shooting. Manuel Bahamon, 25, Alex Lopez, 33, and Ismael Lozada, 25, are each facing one count of first-degree murder and four counts of first-degree attempted murder. They are being held at the Cook County Jail without bond, and their cases are pending.

In the 10 years leading up to 2023, there were 1,500 murders in West Garfield Park, according to a report by the Chicago Sun-Times.

In a statement provided to ESPN, Cook County state's attorney Eileen O'Neill Burke called Griggs "a mother who nurtured her son's exceptional talent."

"The Cook County State's Attorney's Office will vigorously prosecute anyone who endangers the public through these inexcusable acts of violence," O'Neill Burke said. "We are committed to seeking justice on behalf of Ashley and holding those responsible fully accountable in court."

TATE'S TEAMMATES STUCK close to him, taking him out to steak dinners on milestones such as his mom's birthday, asking him if he wanted to talk even though they knew he probably didn't.

Tate kept himself occupied with school and his playbook. Despite a crowded receiver room, he played in all 13 games his freshman season, catching 18 passes for 264 yards and a touchdown in an 11-2 season. Tate had to wait his turn, but he never lost faith in himself or let his sadness sidetrack him. "He never quit on himself or lost any confidence," Baudo said.

"I think his mom played a big part in that."

Shortly after the season, the Buckeyes added graduate transfer Will Howard, and Tate quickly developed a good rapport with the former Kansas State quarterback.

They exchanged sideline feedback on coverages, with Tate sometimes offering suggestions about what he thought might work. Most of the time it did.

Howard, now a quarterback with the Pittsburgh Steelers, said Tate doesn't like to let on how smart he is.

"But he's actually brilliant," Howard said.

"Carnell is kind of a little bit of a Swiss Army knife. He plays bigger than he is. He's strong as hell, and he's really sneaky fast. The thing I think that's so overlooked about his game is how well he blocks. He is a hell of a blocking receiver, and he's super unselfish."

Tate returned home to Chicago in November 2024 to play Northwestern at Wrigley Field. In front of dozens of family members and friends, two days before Ashley would have turned 41, he scored two touchdowns in a 31-7 win.

He started all 15 games, had 52 catches for 733 yards and helped the Buckeyes win a national championship.

At 6-foot-2 and 192 pounds with strong hands and fingers, Tate can manipulate his nimble body in traffic almost effortlessly. As a junior in 2025, he caught 12 of 14 contested passes. Despite missing three games because of a lower-body injury, Tate finished second in the FBS with nine catches of 40 yards or more, and amassed 875 yards and nine touchdowns with zero drops.

He was one of 25 Division I football players to become a first-team Academic All-American.

He blew kisses to the sky to honor his mother when he scored.

THIRTEEN-YEAR-OLD Treyvon Brown became a Carnell Tate fan because Tate catches a lot of footballs and gets good grades. Brown had no idea how much he had in common with the star of his home state's premier team.

On Nov. 2, 2025, Brown's mother, Shakeilah White, was shot and killed in Columbus. Brown's grandfather reached out to ABC affiliate WSYX in the hopes of making a connection with Tate. Maybe, Brent Brown thought, it would boost Treyvon's spirits.

A month later, they met at the Buckeyes' football facility. Tate signed Brown's No. 17 jersey, and, in a conversation aired in the WSYX piece, Tate offered a glimpse into how he has accomplished so much while grappling with grief.

"I think about her every day," Tate told Brown. "There's not going to be a day where you don't think about her. ... And it's OK to accept those feelings.

"You're younger than I was, obviously, so the emotions are definitely different. But just let it out, Bro. You've got a lot of people in your family that's going through the same thing, and you're all going to depend on each other."

Brent Brown told ESPN that Tate spent about 30 minutes with his family. He said Treyvon has followed Tate's advice and leaned on the support of his family when he's feeling down. He said Treyvon is pulling nearly straight-A's in school.

"There's a lot of kids that look up to Carnell Tate," Brent Brown said. "I hope he keeps doing things like that."

AS THE DAYS to the NFL draft draw closer, Astoria Griggs can't help but think about her sister. She has been gone nearly three years, and Astoria sometimes still talks about her in the present tense.

The family's journey to this moment has been a combination of joy in Carnell realizing his NFL dream and sadness knowing Ashley should be here to see it. About a month after her death, Ashley's mom picked out necklaces with Ashley's name on them so the family could carry part of her around. Tate wore his to the NFL combine, and some of his family members undoubtedly will wear theirs on draft day.

Astoria estimates about a dozen people will travel to Pittsburgh to be with Tate at the draft -- his dad, his aunts, his grandma and a few others who've become like family. Astoria knows his mom will be there, too. And she can guess what she'd be saying.

"Tune in," Astoria said. "My son is living out his dream."

Tate has never been one to promote himself. Last fall, he quietly donated JLab headphones to the varsity football players at Marist, a gesture acknowledged on the school's Instagram, not his. Anyone close to him knows he would almost rather sleep in Michigan pajamas than talk to a reporter about his innermost feelings. Through his marketing representative, Tate agreed to do an interview for this story. But it fell through, with the rep citing his busy schedule visiting teams before the draft and other challenges.

Baudo said sometimes Tate even had him tag along on conversations with his agent so Baudo could do most of the talking.

"He's super welcoming," Baudo said of Tate, "and not super outgoing."

So, it's safe to guess that Tate wasn't looking forward to his news conference at the combine.

For about 10 minutes, he stood in front of reporters and talked about his attributes, potential and hopes. True to form, his answers were short and measured.

"If you want a game-changer," he said, "you've got one right here."

"Growing up in Chicago is great. It's a tough city, so you had to learn how to fight. That's all I've been doing is fighting."

In a 21-year-old life filled with so much heartbreak, of quietly keeping his head down toward one goal, the fun part comes next. Carnell Tate is ready. His mom made sure of it.

Toward the end of his time at the news conference, somebody asked Tate who the best receiver is in the draft.

"Me," he said. "No questions. I bring it all to the table. Whatever you need to do, I've got it."