James Garner’s Everton performances make case for Manchester United return

James Garner’s Everton performances make case for Manchester United return

There is something quietly poetic about James Garner potentially returning to Manchester United. The 25-year-old departed Old Trafford without ever being given a real opportunity to prove himself.

Based on Monday evening’s performance at Hill Dickinson Stadium—and his 2025-26 campaign overall—that now looks like one of the more short-sighted decisions United have made in recent years.

Everton drew 3-3 with Manchester City in a breathless encounter, with Garner providing the assist for Jake O’Brien’s goal to make it 2-1—a moment of composure and precision that typified his performance throughout.

Playing at the base of David Moyes’s midfield against one of the Premier League’s most technically accomplished sides, Garner was rarely second-best, winning the ball cleanly, recycling possession intelligently, and driving Everton forward at every opportunity.

He completed 100% of his passes in his own half, won all four of his tackle attempts, and created one big chance. That came as no surprise to those who have watched him consistently over the last couple of months.

Garner has not missed a league game for Everton this season. His 87% passing accuracy is the best in the squad, and he leads the team in interceptions per game (1.6) and tackles per game (3.2).

That level earned him his first cap in March, .