The New York Giants passed on selecting safety Caleb Downs twice during the 2026 NFL draft, opting instead for linebacker Arvell Reese and offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa. This decision surprised many fans and analysts alike.
Key points
Giants passed on Caleb Downs twice in the 2026 NFL draft
Selected linebacker Arvell Reese at No. 5
Selected offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa at No. 10
Decision surprised fans and analysts
Downs was a highly regarded safety from Ohio State
New York GiantsCaleb DownsArvell ReeseFrancis Mauigoa
New York Giants explain why they passed on Caleb Downs twice
Heading into Thursday night's first round of the 2026 NFL draft, one thing was for certain: The New York Giants weren't going home without Ohio State all-world safety Caleb Downs. Until they did.
Much to the shock of their fans, players, and many a pundit, Big Blue passed not once, but twice on Downs in favor of other players at pick Nos. 5 and 10.
At No. 5, the Giants selected Downs' Ohio State teammate, linebacker Arvell Reese, who fell to them unexpectedly. At No. 10, Giants general manager Joe Schoen and head coach John Harbaugh could not pass up Miami offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa, a classic tough guy, to help solve their interior O-Line issues.
Dallas Cowboys (home, away)
Washington Commanders (home, away)
Q&A
Why did the New York Giants pass on Caleb Downs in the 2026 NFL draft?
The Giants chose to select linebacker Arvell Reese and offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa instead of Caleb Downs.
Who did the New York Giants select instead of Caleb Downs?
The Giants selected linebacker Arvell Reese at pick No. 5 and offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa at pick No. 10.
What positions did the Giants address in the 2026 NFL draft?
The Giants addressed their linebacker and offensive line positions by selecting Arvell Reese and Francis Mauigoa.
What was the reaction to the Giants passing on Caleb Downs?
The decision to pass on Caleb Downs surprised fans, players, and analysts, as he was highly regarded leading up to the draft.
Related Articles
Sports
Pep Guardiola cautiously optimistic on Rodri injury ahead of FA Cup semi-final
Yahoo Sports·
Sports
Scales and McCowan sign new Celtic contracts
Yahoo Sports·
Sports
James Forrest is looking to add to medal collection
Yahoo Sports·
Sports
Prep Roundup 4/23: Fairborn breaks out the bats in extra innings win
Yahoo Sports·
Sports
Wittenberg baseball: Tigers play No. 1 Denison in Springfield on Saturday
Yahoo Sports·
Sports
Steelers See Eagles Swoop In, Steal Wide Receiver Target During NFL Draft
See every story in Sports — including breaking news and analysis.
Philadelphia Eagles (home, away)
Arizona Cardinals (home)
Cleveland Browns (home)
Jacksonville Jaguars (home)
New Orleans Saints (home)
San Francisco 49ers (home)
Tennessee Titans (home)
Detroit Lions (road)
Indianapolis Colts (road)
Houston Texans (road)
Seattle Seahawks (road)
Los Angeles Rams (road)
1 / 14
New York Giants vs. Dallas Cowboys: Best photos from Week 18
Dallas Cowboys (home, away)
1 / 14
New York Giants vs. Dallas Cowboys: Best photos from Week 18
Dallas Cowboys (home, away)
2 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Washington Commanders (home, away)
3 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Philadelphia Eagles (home, away)
4 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Arizona Cardinals (home)
5 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Cleveland Browns (home)
6 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Jacksonville Jaguars (home)
7 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
New Orleans Saints (home)
8 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
San Francisco 49ers (home)
9 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Tennessee Titans (home)
10 / 14
New York Giants vs. Detroit Lions: Best photos from Week 12
Detroit Lions (road)
11 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Indianapolis Colts (road)
12 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Houston Texans (road)
13 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Seattle Seahawks (road)
14 / 14
New York Giants' 2026 opponents
Los Angeles Rams (road)
In the end, the Giants landed two 20-year-old studs but had to watch as Downs and another OSU defensive star, linebacker Sonny Styles, ended up in the hands of Dallas and Washington, respectively.
"No. No. We hoped," Schoen said after the Giants drafted Reese on Thursday night. "But there weren't a lot of scenarios that we went through where he may be available."
"Arvell is a versatile player, and we're going to play him at inside backer, Will linebacker," added Harbaugh. "Our defense is pretty flexible, position-less, you might call it. We'll have an opportunity to move those guys around. But he'll line up next to Tremaine (Edmunds), and he'll be in the A gap, the B gap, the C gap, the D gap, off the edge. He'll be moving around with all of our guys.
"He was our highest-rated non-quarterback player in the draft. He's an exciting player. We are fired up to have him."
That answered the question of why they passed on Downs at No. 5. What happened five picks later, though?
"We stuck with the board," said Schoen, who said the Giants landed two of their top four-rated non-quarterbacks in this draft. "And Sisi's another 20-year-old, believe it or not, he'll be 21 in June, so we got two young players that we're fired up about. But a powerful young man with tremendous athleticism and size.
"And I don't know if you guys saw his interview there on TV. They asked him what he should tell Jaxson. And that was, that's the type of kid he is. So again, to get those two young men that have size and athleticism and the makeup that we desire, and the fact that we know that we're going to have those guys under contract for five years, to add to some of the young foundational pieces that we already have, I mean, it's really exciting, really exciting."
For those who missed Mauigoa's message to Dart, here it is...
"That should be everybody's mentality," Sisi went on to say. "As an offensive lineman, we should be able to put everything on the line because the quarterback is the key of the offense. So, to be able to block for a quarterback and to be able to make plays and open up holes for the running back, that's what we're supposed to do. It's not something that people want us to -- It’s something that we're expected to do, that's what we need to do."
