NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year 2026-2027 odds

MORE: Chiefs heiress Gracie Hunt teases personal project

1. David Bailey, New York Jets (+450)

Bailey is the clear early favorite after the Jets took him with the second pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. He also brings the best college résumé on the board, finishing his 2025 season as a unanimous All-American with a Division 1-best 14.5 sacks and a Big 12-best 19.5 tackles for loss. That kind of production makes him the most obvious early Defensive Rookie of the Year bet. The expectation is simple: if he carries that pass-rush impact into the NFL, he will stay near the top of the race all season.

2. Rueben Bain Jr., Tampa Bay Buccaneers (+550)

Bain Jr. sits right behind Bailey on the oddsboard, which shows how strongly the market views his upside. Rueben was names the ACC Defensive players of the year, with 9.5 sacks over 16 games. Tampa Bay has him positioned as one of the most important defensive rookies in the class. If he turns into a steady front-seven presence quickly, he can make this race closer than the current numbers suggest.

3. Arvell Reese, New York Giants (+650)

Reese was one of three Ohio State Buckeyes to go in the first seven picks, landing at No. 5 overall. FOX Sports analyst Rob Rang highlighted his ability to play off the ball and also rush the passer, which gives the Giants flexibility right away. His draft position shows how much teams value his all-around defensive fit. In a race like this, that kind of versatility can matter just as much as raw pressure numbers.

4. Sonny Styles, Washington Commanders (+750)

Styles went No. 7 overall and gives Washington another high-end defensive athlete. Rang compared his size and speed profile to rare linebackers, and he said the Commanders needed an alpha on defense. His solo tackles is 46 and per game tackles is 5.86. If he becomes an every-down impact player, his odds will look better very fast.

5. Caleb Downs, Dallas Cowboys (+750)

Downs is tied near the top of the board and gives Dallas another major defensive rookie to watch. Dallas needed a defensive rebound after last season, and rookies like Downs could be part of that change. His case will depend on how quickly he settles into a consistent role.

6. Mansoor Delane, Kansas City Chiefs (+1000)

Delane gives Kansas City another name to watch in the early Defensive Rookie of the Year race. Being on the board in the top group means the market sees a path for him to produce. Mansoor Delane recorded 2 interceptions, 7 pass breakups, and 54 tackles, allowing just 14 receptions with a 31.3 passer rating.

7. Akheem Mesidor, Los Angeles Chargers (+1600)

Mesidor comes in as a longer shot, but he still appears on the board as a player with upside. In 2025, Akheem Mesidor recorded 63 tackles, 17.5 tackles for loss, 12.5 sacks, and four forced fumbles in 15 games. That makes his path more difficult than the players above him. Still, players in this range can rise quickly if they turn into regular contributors early in the season.

8. Malachi Lawrence, Dallas Cowboys (+1800)

Lawrence gives Dallas another defensive rookie with a chance to earn snaps. His odds reflect the challenge of breaking through on a roster with multiple young defensive additions.

9. Dillon Thieneman, Chicago Bears (+2000)

Thieneman is one of the lower-priced names on the board, but he is still close enough to matter. In 2025, Dillon Thieneman recorded 86 tackles, two interceptions, seven pass breakups, 3.5 tackles for loss, and one sack. In a crowded rookie race, that makes his climb harder, but not impossible. A strong start would be enough to change his outlook.

10. Jacob Rodriguez, Miami Dolphins (+2200)

Rodriguez is in the longer-shot tier, but he remains on the radar for early season award talk. In 2025, Jacob Rodriguez recorded 122 tackles, 11 tackles for loss, four interceptions, and won Big 12 Defensive Player of the Year. For any rookie defender, the first step is getting on the field often enough to matter.

11. CJ Allen, Indianapolis Colts (+2200)

Allen rounds out the board and gives Indianapolis another rookie defender to track. In 2025, CJ Allen recorded 88 tackles, 8 tackles for loss, 3.5 sacks, and two forced fumbles in 13 games. This is what makes him relevant. At this stage, though, he sits behind the more established early favorites.

MORE: Which 2026 NFL Draft picks are selling the most jerseys?

Conclusion

The 2026 Defensive Rookie of the Year race starts with Bailey, but it is far from settled. Early draft capital, fast playing time, and strong college production will decide a lot before the season is over. If one of these rookies gets hot early, the oddsboard could look very different by midseason.