The Red Sox need to move on from Trevor Story

TL;DR

The Boston Red Sox should part ways with Trevor Story due to his poor performance and inability to contribute effectively to the team. Despite his hard work, he ranks among the worst players in MLB and is not meeting the standards expected from a player with his contract.

Key points

Trevor Story ranks among the worst players in MLB
He has the most errors among shortstops aside from a few others
The Red Sox are struggling with suboptimal lineups
Moving on from Story would signal a commitment to winning

Boston Red SoxTampa Bay Rays

May 7, 2026; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Boston Red Sox shortstop Trevor Story (10) scores a run on Boston Red Sox center fielder Ceddanne Rafaela (3) (not pictured) RBI infield single against the Tampa Bay Rays during the second inning at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: Gregory Fisher-Imagn Images | Gregory Fisher-Imagn Images The Boston Red Sox are mid… I’ll be the first to admit that it’s looking like “mid” might be enough to secure one of the final playoff spots in the American League in 2026, but you aren’t exactly allowed to fall under that distinction when you’re routinely trotting out suboptimal lineups, unable to play the brand of baseball you’ve been built to play, and trying but failing to change the framework of how your organization is run (i.e. cheaping out). It’s a shitshow, folks. I don’t like being the negative guy, especially so short into my run jotting words down onto this virtual diary, but the organization has given me no choice but to watch the piss poor product they trot out onto the field and look for ways to fix it. How? What? Who? I’ve asked myself those questions routinely over the last several weeks, and always seem to end up pointing in the direction of one man: Trevor Story. Story, in all fairness, has been nothing short of hardworking during his time with the local nine. I’d have quit after my third season-ending injury, but this guy has routinely worked through difficult circumstances to get back out onto the field and try to play up to the standard of that six-year, $140 million contract he signed in 2022. If you can’t respect that, you’re probably an a-hole. It’s just not about respect, it’s about the fact that he’s one of the worst players in all of baseball. Story currently ranks near the bottom of these lists in MLB, as shared by :

Q&A

Why should the Red Sox move on from Trevor Story?

The Red Sox should move on from Trevor Story because he ranks near the bottom in multiple performance metrics and is one of the worst defensive shortstops in baseball.

What are Trevor Story's current performance rankings in MLB?

Trevor Story ranks 174th in wRC+, 176th in xwOBA, and 172nd in fWAR among 177 players, indicating a significant decline in his performance.

How many errors has Trevor Story made this season?

Trevor Story has made five errors this season, making him one of the worst defensive shortstops in MLB.

What impact would releasing Trevor Story have on the Red Sox?

Releasing Trevor Story would send a clear message about the team's commitment to winning and could improve the overall performance of the roster.