The Road Through Ann Arbor: No. 2 Northwestern lacrosse’s path to a Big Ten Tournament four-peat

The Other Side of the Bracket: The Gauntlet

No. 2 Maryland (14-2)

The Terrapins are the boogeyman of this bracket, and they will arrive in Ann Arbor with a chip on their shoulder the size of a national title trophy.

To understand why, you have to look past this season and into the deep history of this rivalry. Maryland and Northwestern are the two most successful programs in Division I women’s lacrosse history. The Terrapins have won a record 14 national titles; the Wildcats have claimed eight of their own, all under current head coach Kelly Amonte Hiller. Before the Big Ten even existed as a lacrosse conference, these programs were already meeting on the sport’s biggest stages. They clashed in the national championship game in 2010 (Maryland won), 2011 (Northwestern won), and 2014 (Maryland won), with additional semifinal meetings in 2012 and 2015.

When Maryland joined the Big Ten, the rivalry became a yearly obligation. And for years, the Terps owned it. In 2015, Maryland demolished Northwestern 16-5 in the first ever Big Ten conference game, holding the Wildcats to a meager five goals. The following year, then-No. 1 Maryland routed No. 14 Northwestern 17-4, extending their home winning streak to 46 games and outscoring Northwestern 50-14 across their previous three meetings. For a program that built its dynasty by beating Maryland in the NCAA tournament, those regular season beatings stung.

Now the tables have turned. Northwestern handed Maryland its only regular season loss of the season in an 11-10 thriller on April 9, the Wildcats’ second victory over a No. 1 ranked opponent this year (joining their overtime win at North Carolina), a feat no team has accomplished since Florida in 2012. The Wildcats have now beaten the Terrapins in two of their last three meetings dating back to last season. Maryland has not forgotten any of it. They have not forgotten the heartbreak of last year’s Big Ten Tournament loss to Northwestern in College Park. They have not forgotten that NU ended their perfect Big Ten record in the 2019 tournament final. They have not forgotten that the Wildcats ended their undefeated season this year and knocked them off the No. 1 ranking. For a program with Maryland’s pedigree, all of that stings. They will be desperate to prove that the 11-10 loss was a fluke and that they remain the standard in this sport.

The Maryland threat: A historically elite program playing with desperation, featuring an athletic roster and a defense that has held 11 of 16 opponents to single-digit goals this season. Plus, the dual-threat attack of Kori Edmondson and Lauren LaPointe is one of the best offensive duos in the country.

Why Northwestern is fine anyway: The Wildcats rank second in the nation in draw controls per game, anchored by the dynamic duo of Maddie Epke and Madison Smith. Epke pulled down a season-high 15 draw controls against then-undefeated North Carolina, a figure tied for the fourth most in a single game in program history. Smith, a Second Team All-Big Ten selection who recorded 10 draw controls against Syracuse earlier this season, gives Northwestern a two-headed possession monster. No matter how much desperation Maryland carries onto the field, they cannot score without the ball. Northwestern’s dominance on the draw circle ensures they control tempo and keep Maryland’s offense watching from the sideline.

No. 3 Johns Hopkins (13-3)

Don’t sleep on the Blue Jays. While they are known for their disruptive, defense-first style anchored by Reagan O’Brien (a Second Team All-Big Ten honoree and second all-time in NCAA caused turnovers with 233 career takeaways), labeling them as a one-dimensional team would be a serious mistake. Their offense is equally high-powered, and the regular season meeting between these two teams on March 29 provided all the evidence you need.

In that game at Northwestern, the Wildcats escaped with a 16-12 victory, but it was far from comfortable. Johns Hopkins put up 12 goals against a defense that has smothered most opponents, and their resilience throughout the game was genuinely impressive. Lacey Downey, a unanimous First Team All-Big Ten selection, led the Blue Jays with six points, while Ava Angello (First Team All-Big Ten) and freshman Sienna Chirieleison (All-Freshman Team) each recorded hat tricks. What stands out most on film is how Johns Hopkins responded to every Northwestern run. After the Wildcats built a 4-2 lead, Hopkins answered with two quick goals to tie the game at 4-4. When Northwestern pushed ahead 7-5, the Blue Jays responded immediately with goals from Downey and Taylor Hoss just 62 seconds apart to pull level at 7-7 heading into halftime. That kind of fight, combined with three All-Big Ten contributors on offense, forced Northwestern’s stars to put up extraordinary individual numbers just to secure a four-goal win.

The Johns Hopkins threat: Reagan O’Brien’s 233 career caused turnovers anchor one of the most disruptive defenses in the country, while an offense featuring three All-Big Ten selections (Downey, Angello, and O’Brien) proved it can hang 12 goals on the Wildcats in Evanston.

Why Northwestern is fine anyway: They have already solved this puzzle, and they solved it convincingly. In the March 29 meeting, the Hopkins defense had no answer for the combination of Madison Taylor and Maddie Epke. Taylor erupted for six goals while Epke added five of her own. The duo combined for 11 goals, and 11 of Northwestern’s 16 total goals were assisted, demonstrating that this is not an isolation offense that can be shut down by locking up one player. It is a fluid, ball-movement attack that neutralizes even the best on-ball defenders in the country. Jenika Cuocco added 11 saves when Hopkins did manage to break through. Northwestern has already seen Johns Hopkins’s best shot and came away with a four-goal win. A second meeting will come with even more preparation.

Why Northwestern Wins the Title

The analysis for the Wildcats comes down to four distinct advantages. But before diving in, consider this: Northwestern placed nine players on All-Big Ten teams this season. Nine. That is a massive chunk of the starting lineup earning conference recognition. Noel Cumberland and Madison Taylor represent the Wildcats on the First Team. Annabel Child, Jenika Cuocco, Aditi Foster, Jaylen Rosga, and Madison Smith landed on the Second Team. Freshmen Kate Ratanaproeksa (a unanimous selection) and Mckenzie Brown made the All-Freshman Team. The sheer depth of talent on this roster is staggering. When your depth players are still conference honorees, you have a margin for error that no other program in this bracket can match.

1. The Road Warriors

Northwestern is 16-0 away from home over the last two seasons. They have already walked into the nation’s toughest environments, including a victory at No. 1 North Carolina and a road win at No. 1 Maryland, and come away with wins both times. Playing a semifinal and potential final in Michigan’s home stadium removes the travel variable that typically plagues lower seeds. These Wildcats are simply immune to hostile crowds.

2. Why Northwestern Takes Down Michigan Again

The Wildcats have a proven blueprint for neutralizing Michigan’s best weapon in Calli Norris, and they have executed it at the highest level. In last year’s NCAA tournament, Northwestern held Norris to just one goal after she had scored five in the previous round by relentlessly pushing her to her non-dominant hand. That same defensive discipline was on display in the April 18 regular season finale, a 9-7 Northwestern win in this exact stadium. Beyond the X’s and O’s, Northwestern simply owns this matchup. Entering their 20th all-time meeting, the Wildcats are 19-0 against the Wolverines. In the recent 9-7 win, Northwestern erased a two-goal deficit in the fourth quarter with a 4-0 run, proving they have the clutch gene when it matters most. That psychological edge is impossible to quantify and impossible to ignore.

3. The Inevitable Madison Taylor

Let’s be direct about the best player on the field in any game she plays. Madison Taylor is a First Team All-Big Ten selection for the third consecutive season, and she leads the conference in both goals and points, having already put up 77 goals and 104 points this season. She is the active leader among all NCAA Division I players in career goals and points, and she is hunting history: 35 points behind Izzy Scane’s Wildcat record of 483 points and 50 away from Kylie Ohlmiller’s career NCAA record. What makes Taylor truly unstoppable is her consistency in the moments that define tournament runs. Against Maryland, she scored four goals, including the equalizer in the fourth quarter. Against Johns Hopkins, she exploded for six goals and took over the game when her team needed her most. Against Michigan in the April 18 finale, she was the steady hand that guided the comeback. In tournament settings where games tighten and every possession is precious, having a player of her caliber is the ultimate trump card. Michigan, Maryland, and Johns Hopkins all have All-Big Ten defenders. None of them have an answer for her.

4. Why Northwestern Handles the Gauntlet on the Other Side

Whether Maryland or Johns Hopkins emerges from the other semifinal, Northwestern has already beaten both this season and has specific, proven counter-punches ready. Against Maryland, the draw control dominance of Epke and Smith suffocates possessions, ensuring the Terrapins cannot capitalize on their desperation. Against Johns Hopkins, the offensive firepower of Taylor and company and the goaltending of Cuocco (11 saves in that same game) have already cracked the code. On top of this, it is not like Northwestern can not have all of these factors succeed at the same time. These players are not Blue Jays or Terrapins specific, they are elite no matter what. The Wildcats have seen every look these opponents can throw at them and have emerged victorious each time. And those victories came with the whole squad contributing. That depth is a luxury no other team in this bracket comes close to matching.

The prediction: Michigan will keep it close for a half, with Burke winning possessions and the home crowd providing real energy. But Northwestern’s defense locks down Norris, the offense eventually overpowers the Wolverines, and the Wildcats punch their ticket to the final. That sets up a championship rematch against Maryland, a continuation of one of the sport’s greatest rivalries. In the final, Madison Taylor delivers another signature performance, Jenika Cuocco shuts the door late, and nine All-Big Ten selections prove why Northwestern is the deepest team in the conference.

Fourth straight. Bank it.