The Yankees don’t do themselves any favors

Apr 11, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; New York Yankees second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. (13) throws to first against the Tampa Bay Rays in the second inning at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images | Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

This is not solely a piece to bash Jazz Chisholm Jr. I think he’s a very good player, and I am currently watching him relay signs while standing on second base, both to help his own hitters and mess with Rays’ starter Drew Rassmussen. I think he brings an energy to the club that they’ve needed for a little while.

And then, there’s stuff like this:

This is not solely a piece to bash Jazz, but I think he’s illustrative of a problem the Yankees have had for a number of years now. For all the very real talent they boast, they’re constantly getting into their own way. Chisholm Jr. is a genuine perennial All Star type of talent. but if you’re going to brag about a 50/50 season, you can’t have a 42 wRC+ in the season’s first two weeks, and you definitely can’t be admitting you don’t know the rules.

In the same vein, the team that went so viral for being “savages in the box”, and pushes to the public how much their hitters own the strike zone, you can’t be the fourth-worst in the game in hitter ABS challenges — giving away strikes and the limited number of reviews you can ask for. Funny enough Jazz is one of nine players tied for just a 25 percent challenge success rate, the worst mark in the game. Ben Rice, one of the few Yankees that have really shown up this year, has just now joined Jazz at 1-4. Of course there was reporting just this weekend that José Caballero had to be pulled aside by Aaron Boone and have the importance of getting challenges right re-asserted in a one on one meeting.

Pair that weakness with the fact that a team built around working counts and wearing down opposing pitching has possibly taken all that too far, to the point where they’re downright passive. Swinging at strikes just 62.7 percent of the time, the Yankees are only more…judicious (to put it charitably) than the Red Sox and Diamondbacks, and last year while they were the best offense in baseball they were offering at pitches in the zone five points higher, still selective while not allowing themselves to give up even more free strikes.

Part of this is just being reactive to the first rough patch of the season. The team managed a series win against the Marlins by the skin of their teeth, before dropping a trap series to the Athletics and not playing well at the Trop, none of those things in isolation would mean all that much. All of baseball is sequencing, putting together 14 hits in a game doesn’t mean much if they’re spread evenly across all nine innings — you need an inning or two with four or five hits to do real damage. If the Yankees went to Tropicana Field in July while in first place in the division and didn’t play well, that’d be annoying, and if Jazz was hitting to his level while making a moronic play defensively we’d all have a “Jazz being Jazz” kind of attitude — the kind of attitude that has built more than one Hall of Very Good career.

Instead it comes when it comes, at this confluence of events where it looks like the Yankees have tied their own shoelaces together. We don’t know yet if this is some bump on the road we’ll forget about when the club’s in the division hunt in September or an early harbinger of the risk of “running it back because we’re good enough”. In the meantime though, let’s learn how double plays work.