Why the Carolina Panthers should be in on the Brendan Sorsby sweepstakes

Instead, he would likely enter the supplemental draft. Sorsby was eligible for the 2026 NFL Draft and seen as a mid-season riser before ultimately turning to the transfer portal instead. If the NCAA hands down a punishment, Sorsby can try his hand at the next level while avoiding a suspension.

The supplemental draft works as a kind of silent auction, where teams can bid future selections (say, their 2027 second-round pick) for players deemed ineligible for NCAA competition. Most of the buzz around Sorsby suggests that it'll take a second-round pick and a fortunate tiebreaker to win his services. Others have speculated that a third-round pick could be enough, considering the inherent media storm attached to such a selection.

The Panthers should be one of the teams offering up a Day 2 selection. For one, Sorsby is many of the things Young isn't as a passer. At 6'3" and 235 pounds, he looks the part in ways Young never will. Young's stature caps his impact, limiting his ability over the middle of the field, forcing him to rely more on anticipation, and shrinking the margins across his profile. He doesn't have the standout arm talent or elite athleticism necessary to write off those concerns, either.

Sorsby has both tools in spades.

There are certainly issues to iron out. At Cincinnati, Sorsby posted fringe Day 2 film and has long been seen as a bit of a projection. His physical traits were bound to push him up the board, and his profile wasn't bulletproof. Despite an ability to avoid turnovers, he lacked the consistency to trust as an immediate starter. Sorsby struggled with pressure -- despite limiting sacks -- and fell short against the best defenses on his schedule. He's not a starter-level processor yet, either.

MORE:Lee Hunter creates mammoth minicamp impression

Sorsby is an upside play, and one Carolina isn't well-positioned to add. The Panthers weren't sustainable winners in 2025. Ranking 24th and 23rd in offensive and defensive EPA/Play, respectively, there's plenty of work to be done. The playoff drought ended, but the losing season drought didn't. A -69 point differential isn't making 2026 projections any rosier.

Even Young's best season failed to inspire much optimism. His career year, to date, fell almost equidistant from Tyler Shough and Spencer Rattler by EPA/Play. His career 6.0 yards per attempt is worse than David Carr and Blaine Gabbert.

However, in the NFC South, anything is possible, and if Carolina finds itself in the playoffs again, it'd be awfully difficult to land a prospect with Sorsby's upside. In the supplemental draft, they'd be getting a discount on a passer with more tangible upside than Young, albeit wrapped in an off-field concern.

Panthers head coach Dave Canales might be the right man to foster Sorsby's development, both on and off the field. Hired to change the trajectory of Young's career, Canales has proven success in changing quarterbacks like Geno Smith and Baker Mayfield for the better. For what it's worth, Canales also overcame off-field issues during his coaching journey.

Canales may be working his magic again with Young, but there's only so much production one can coax out of this small a frame. Sitting behind Young would provide Sorsby the opportunity to refine his game like he would have at Texas Tech while insulating Carolina's passing offense and adding variance (in both directions) should Young be sidelined.

Barring disaster, the Panthers won't be picking early enough to change course at quarterback in 2027, even if Young's development demands competition. Before Carolina is positioned to extend its quarterback, spending a Day 2 pick on an off-ramp could pry open a competitive window that is yet to open.

More Panthers news

• One reason to worry about Xavier Legette
• UDFA QB Haynes King takes perfecting plays to the parking lot
• Monroe Freeling growing into NFL role
• Jaycee Horn agrees to restructure contract