Yankees facing roster dilemma and their deadline for a solution is today

The New York Yankees are doing exactly what contenders are supposed to do. They’re winning. In fact, they currently lead the American League in wins, fueled by the most dominant starting pitching in MLB. They have also gotten strong defense and timely hitting. On the surface, everything looks stable. But underneath that success is a growing problem, one that’s about to force a major decision from manager Aaron Boone and GM Brian Cashman.

MORE: Giancarlo Stanton injury update is promising news for Yankees

An Unexpected Breakout at Shortstop

One of the Yankees’ biggest strengths this season has come at shortstop. While Anthony Volpe recovered from offseason shoulder surgery, José Caballero stepped in and hasn’t given the job back.

Caballero has:

• Been one of the team’s hottest hitters
• Led the American League in stolen bases
• Played excellent defense at a premium position

Simply put, he’s been too good to take out of the lineup. Now comes the problem. Volpe’s 20-day rehab assignment is ending, and the Yankees must decide whether to activate him or keep him in the minors. This isn’t just a routine roster move. It’s a decision with real consequences.

Short-Term Success vs Long-Term Investment

Volpe is still viewed as a key part of the Yankees’ future. That raises an important question: What happens if they don’t give him his job back?

Keeping him in the minors or reducing his role could:

• Impact his development
• Shake his confidence
• Send a confusing message about his standing in the organization

But at the same time, removing Caballero from the lineup right now feels like forcing a problem that doesn’t exist.

Is There a Middle Ground?

The Yankees could try to get creative. One option could be to get Volpe back in at SS while keeping Caballero in the lineup by shifting him to third base and pushing Ryan McMahon to the bench. While McMahon offers solid defense, his offensive production has been among the weakest in the lineup, making him the most logical candidate to lose playing time.

But even that solution isn’t perfect. Position changes, lineup adjustments, and role shifts all come with risk.

A Good Problem—But Still a Problem

This is the kind of dilemma most teams would love to have: Too many productive players. But that doesn’t make it easy. Because now the Yankees must choose between:

• Rewarding current performance
• Investing in long-term development
• Or trying to balance both without disrupting what’s working

The Yankees are winning, but that only raises the stakes of this decision. There’s no easy answer. But whatever they choose, it won’t just affect today’s lineup. It could shape the future of the roster.

— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead—