Meadowbrook defeated Indian Creek 17-1 in a five-inning playoff game, showcasing a dominant performance. Senior Addy Sichina contributed significantly with two home runs and a strong pitching display, allowing only one run on two hits.
Key points
Meadowbrook won 17-1 against Indian Creek
Addy Sichina hit two home runs
Sichina allowed one run on two hits
The game lasted five innings
It was an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal
Meadowbrook ColtsIndian CreekOHSAA Division IV Eastern DistrictAddy Sichina
Meadowbrook senior Addy Sichina (1) delivers a pitch during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. Sichina had a big night allowing just one run on two hits to pick up the pitching win, and also belted a pair of home runs to lead Meadowbrook..
Meadowbrook assistan coach Bridget George gives instructions to base runner Addie Schultice (8) during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook senior Sommer Ginn (9) connects with the ball during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook cleanup hitter McKendall Boyer (15) waits for a pitch during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Q&A
What was the final score of the Meadowbrook vs. Indian Creek playoff game?
The final score was Meadowbrook 17, Indian Creek 1.
Who was the standout player in the Meadowbrook playoff game against Indian Creek?
Senior Addy Sichina was the standout player, hitting two home runs and earning the pitching win.
How many innings did the Meadowbrook vs. Indian Creek game last?
The game lasted five innings.
What division was the Meadowbrook vs. Indian Creek playoff game part of?
The game was part of the OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinals.
Related Articles
MLB·Recap
Dodgers aren’t cashing in scoring chances, and aren’t creating them either
Dodgers' offensive woes continue as they fail to score runs and capitalize on chances.
Yahoo Sports··1 min read
Sports·Feature
How has FSU softball performed in the last five NCAA Tournaments?
A look at FSU softball's journey through the last five NCAA Tournaments.
Yahoo Sports··1 min read
MLB
One Stat To Tell the Story of Each Blue Jays Hitter’s Season
Analyzing Key Stats for the Blue Jays Hitters in 2026
Yahoo Sports··1 min read
Soccer·Preview
When can Arsenal win the title? Premier League permutations as Man City take on Crystal Palace
Arsenal can clinch the Premier League title with two wins; City plays Palace soon.
Yahoo Sports··1 min read
Cricket·Feature
Who is the most-capped player in IPL history? Virat Kohli scripts history during KKR clash
Virat Kohli makes history as the most-capped player in IPL during KKR clash!
Yahoo Sports··1 min read
Sports
Igor Arrieta conquista Potenza en un final de etapa épico y surrealista: hay cambio de 'maglia' en el Giro
Igor Arrieta del UAE Team Emirates-XRG conquista Potenza en el Giro de Italia tras un final épico.
See every story in Sports — including breaking news and analysis.
Meadowbrook freshman Addie Schultice (8) stands at second base during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook's Sommer Ginn, left, celebrates with Natalee Norman, right, following a successful put out during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook senior Addy Sichina (11) gets in some practice swings during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. That extra practice paid off with Sichina belting a pair of home runs in the game to lead Meadowbrook.
Meadowbrook sophomore Bella Eubanks (11) slides safely into third base during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook senior Jordyn Vargeson (19) connects to put the ball in play during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook senior Jordyn Vargeson (19) arrives at third base during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook senior Jordyn Vargeson (19) stands at third base during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Happy teammates greet Meadowbrook senior Addy SIchina (1) at home plate following her second home run of the game during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
1 / 12
Meadowbrook's 'big stage' experience shines in playoff rout of Indian Creek
Meadowbrook senior Addy Sichina (1) delivers a pitch during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. Sichina had a big night allowing just one run on two hits to pick up the pitching win, and also belted a pair of home runs to lead Meadowbrook..
1 / 12
Meadowbrook's 'big stage' experience shines in playoff rout of Indian Creek
Meadowbrook senior Addy Sichina (1) delivers a pitch during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. Sichina had a big night allowing just one run on two hits to pick up the pitching win, and also belted a pair of home runs to lead Meadowbrook..
2 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook assistan coach Bridget George gives instructions to base runner Addie Schultice (8) during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
3 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook senior Sommer Ginn (9) connects with the ball during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
4 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook cleanup hitter McKendall Boyer (15) waits for a pitch during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
5 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook freshman Addie Schultice (8) stands at second base during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
6 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook's Sommer Ginn, left, celebrates with Natalee Norman, right, following a successful put out during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
7 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook senior Addy Sichina (11) gets in some practice swings during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. That extra practice paid off with Sichina belting a pair of home runs in the game to lead Meadowbrook.
8 / 12
Meadowbrook's 'big stage' experience shines in playoff rout of Indian Creek
Meadowbrook sophomore Bella Eubanks (11) slides safely into third base during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
9 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook senior Jordyn Vargeson (19) connects to put the ball in play during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
10 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook senior Jordyn Vargeson (19) arrives at third base during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
11 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Meadowbrook senior Jordyn Vargeson (19) stands at third base during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
12 / 12
Colts roll past Creek in Division IV quarterfinal to open OHSAA postseason
Happy teammates greet Meadowbrook senior Addy SIchina (1) at home plate following her second home run of the game during the Colts 17-1 five inning OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
BYESVILLE −Meadowbrook head coach Doug Pfeffer wanted his squad to make a statement in their postseason debut, and the Colts delivered a loud one.
Behind a powerful dual-threat performance from senior Addy Sichina and a perfect night from freshman Addie Schultice, the No. 3 seeded Colts began their quest for a fourth consecutive regional appearance with a dominant 17-1 romp over No. 13 Indian Creek in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup on Tuesday, May 12.
The victory improves Meadowbrook to 19-6 on the season and moves them one step closer to their perennial goal of another deep postseason run.
Lighting the fuse
Meadowbrook wasted little time seizing control on their home field, jumping out to a 9-0 lead after just three innings of play. The tone was set in the very first frame, not just with the bats, but with a defensive gem. Junior third baseman Natalee Norman ignited the dugout with a spectacular diving catch that turned into a double play that robbed Indian Creek of any early momentum.
"We came out fast with the bats, Sich (Addy Sichina) pitched great, and we played great defense starting in the first inning with a great diving catch from Natalee," Coach Pfeffer noted.
The offense followed Norman's lead immediately, by plating four runs in the opening frame, capped by a towering blast over the center-field fence off the bat of Sichina to quickly seize control.
Offensive explosion
The Colts' lineup was relentless, banging out 13 hits in the shortened five-inning contest. While SIchina was clinical in the circle−allowing just one run on two hits with four strikeouts over five innings−she was equally lethal at the plate. The senior standout finished 3-for-4 with a pair of solo home runs and a single with two RBIs.
Meadowbrook senior Addy Sichina (1) delivers a pitch during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. Sichina had a big night allowing just one run on two hits to pick up the pitching win, and also belted a pair of home runs to lead Meadowbrook..
Meadowbrook senior Addy Sichina (1) delivers a pitch during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. Sichina had a big night allowing just one run on two hits to pick up the pitching win, and also belted a pair of home runs to lead Meadowbrook..
She wasn't alone in the hit parade for the Colts. Freshman Addie Schultice turned in a perfect 3-for-3 effort, finishing just a home run short of the cycle with a triple, a double, a single and three RBIs. Senior Sommer Ginn provided reinforcement, collecting three singles and a team-high four RBIs, while Norman added two singles to the tally.
"We really drove the ball well tonight; I told the girls to just hit line drives and the ball will go," Pfeffer said. Sich hit two out to complete a very big night for her."
While the opening-round win was decisive, it was the business-like approach of the Colts that stood out. For a roster filled with multi-sport athletes, the pressure of OHSAA postseason play is familiar territory.
"These girls know the drill, not only from success with three straight trips to regionals in softball," Pfeffer said of his team's postseason experience. "Most of these girls have also played in regional and state volleyball. They have been there, done that on the big stage.
That "Big Stage" experience will be vital as the stakes rise.
Meadowbrook sophomore Bella Eubanks (11) slides safely into third base during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
Meadowbrook sophomore Bella Eubanks (11) slides safely into third base during the Colts 17-1, five inning victory in an OHSAA Division IV Eastern District quarterfinal matchup with Indian Creek on Tuesday, May 12, 2026.
"On your home field you want to come out and make a statement," Pfeffer added. "It's step one in the postseason, and everybody is 0-0. We were able to do that tonight and get off to a good start."
The road to the regionals continues next week. By virtue of Tuesday's victory, No. 3 Meadowbrook advances to the Division IV Eastern District semifinals on Monday, May 18, where they will host No. 5 seed West Holmes at 5 p.m.
